Garden State (VHS, 2005)

56 ratings (52 Epinions reviews)
Epinions Product Rating: Excellent
5 stars
22
4 stars
21
3 stars
5
2 stars
2
1 star
2
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

Uncomfortably Numb

Sep 12, 2004
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review

Pros:Draws us all the way in.

Cons:Ending too pat.

The Bottom Line: Baby we were born to run to this movie.


When I was a child I caught a fleeting glimpse
Out of the corner of my eye
I turned to look but it was gone
I cannot put my finger on it now
The child has grown and the dream is gone
-Pink Floyd

That's just how Andrew Largeman (Zach Braff) feels at the beginning of Garden State. A former Jersey boy who felt born to run out of the Garden State and on to what he hoped would be a successful acting career, Large (as his friends call him) supports himself as a busboy in a Vietnamese restaurant. His only acting job so far has been as a retarded quarterback and his numbness has been exacerbated by the high number of prescription medications he takes (two whole cabinets full). He's so out of touch with life that he doesn't realize (in an early scene in the movie) that the nozzle from the gas station is still in his gas tank until he arrives at work.

This all changes when he gets a call from his estranged father that his paraplegic mother has kicked the bucket, Jim Morrison style. Reluctantly, Large hops the plane back home for the funeral where he meets up with dad and old and new friends. And over the course of the movie, old wounds are re-opened, a search for the meaning of life is undertaken and various people and things team up to try to break Andrew from his numbness.

It’s tempting to compare Garden State with American Beauty and in some ways it could be seen as the twentysomething version of that mid-life crisis film. However in overall terms, a comparison between the two isn’t that relevant as Garden State is about the same lost souls. But the approach it takes is different.

In American Beauty, all of the characters were people whose numbness pushed them towards the illicit side of life. Here, aside from a near-speeding ticket, there’s little of that immorality. There is some question of whether or nor Large may have committed an immoral act as a boy that led his mother to her paraplegic state. But overall, the majority of the characters in here are your ordinary twentysomethings just out of college, still hesitant about joining the so-called rat race. A few of them (aside from Large) have been noted for making a few contributions here and there (one in particular invented a noiseless Velcro). Yet as Peter Saarsgard’s character says early on in the film “I’m okay with being unimpressive. I sleep better”.

That is where the central conflict of Garden State lies, between staying in your own little world and joining the real world. Some characters have joined the real world (including a high school buddy of Large who works as a knight at Medieval Times) while some are halfway there and some need that big push. The central message, which isn’t forced too hard, is that while the real world may be scary and dangerous, it’s also wonderfully alive.

The New Jersey of Garden State is different from Tony Soprano’s New Jersey. Here it’s a world of swimming pools and small suburban houses with a garbage dump thrown in for good measure. Inserted among the scenes are bits of modern rock music as well as one classic Simon and Garfunkel number (“The Only Living Boy In New York”).

Braff directed the film as well as writing and starring in it and amazingly he does all three quite well. His writing and direction keeps the film free of characters that don’t figure into it and keeps the supporting characters to the exact level that they’re needed. Braff’s acting is just as good, as he starts the film off by giving us a tortured Andrew and slow allowing him to see that there is still good out there. Natalie Portman improves noticeably from her Queen Amidala role and reminds us that she can act with her role as Samantha, a potential love interest for Large. Saarsgard is good too, as is Ian Holm as Large’s father.

Especially good is the mix of humor and pathos. Garden State is smart and it treats its audience that way as well. It never condescends or dumbs down to appeal to the teenybopper market. The film seems to sense that most of the people watching will be actual young adults (Mid twenties to early thirties) and it respects that. The only real flaw is the ending, which seems a bit too pat.

So in the end, Garden State emerges as a late contender for movie of the summer. In an era of product, it reminds us of the main reason we go to the movies in the first place.


Recommend this product? Yes

Read all comments (1)

Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!


Related Deals You Might Like...

Garden Innovations SG1000 10-Inch by 10-Foot Roll Out Flowers, Shady Garden

Garden Innovations SG1000 10-Inch by 10-Foot Roll Out Flowers, Shady Garden

New. Roll Out Flowers is an easy to grow garden in a box, simply roll out on soil and add water. Gorgeous blooms in 3 easy steps. Contains over 2000 p...
Sears Marketplace
Personalized Home State Garden Flag

Personalized Home State Garden Flag

If you're proud of your home state then this is just the personalized garden flag to display in your yard. No matter what the time of year it's never ...
GiftsForYouNow

$15.98

+$5.69 shipping
Suncast 8-Panel Garden Kit

Suncast 8-Panel Garden Kit

Grow your favorite flowers or vegetables and make them the center of attention in your garden with the Suncast 8-Panel Raised Garden Bed Kit. It is a ...
Walmart.com

$85.48

FREE Shipping
Garden Size Flag, Va State (print), 11364

Garden Size Flag, Va State (print), 11364

Every buyer gets a MyStoreRewards invitation for cash back This is garden size flag, the size is: 13x18. Need Garden Stand to display; I do combined s...
eBay

$9.99

+$2.68 shipping
Virginia State Garden Size Applique Flag

Virginia State Garden Size Applique Flag

Show your Virginia pride with the highest quality official flag of the Virginia state---designed right here in Richmond! Excellent craftsmanship has m...
eBay

$9.49

FREE Shipping
Penn State Applique Garden Flag

Penn State Applique Garden Flag

Fly your Penn State pride proudly with this Nittany Lions applique garden flag. The Penn State logo is appliqued on both side and PENN STATE is writte...
Nittany Outlet.com

$8.09

+$5.85 shipping
Liberty Garden Multi Purpose Wall Mount Hose Reel Multicolor - 703-2

Liberty Garden Multi Purpose Wall Mount Hose Reel Multicolor - 703-2

Shop for Hose Reels and Organizers from Hayneedle.com! The versatile Liberty Garden Multi Purpose Wall Mount Hose Reel mounts to any exterior wall, an...
Hayneedle

$81.20

FREE Shipping
Liberty Garden 200 ft. 3-in-1 Hose Reel

Liberty Garden 200 ft. 3-in-1 Hose Reel

Shop for Garden Center at The Home Depot. The versatile 703 hose reel is a heavy duty, solid wall mounted reel. It also anchors to the lawn or you can...
Home Depot

$69.99

FREE Shipping
Garden Weasel Long Handled Garden Claw 91311

Garden Weasel Long Handled Garden Claw 91311

Garden Weasel 91311 Features: -Garden claw.-Material: Steel.-Cultivates, loosens, aerates and weeds any soil.-Ergonomic handle system.-Spiral turn act...
Wayfair

$25.47

+$4.99 shipping
Garden Weasel Red Garden Claw (Garden Weasel 91316 Garden Claw Red)

Garden Weasel Red Garden Claw (Garden Weasel 91316 Garden Claw Red)

This helpful Garden Claw by Garden Weasel features four main uses to work around your yard, cultivating, loosening, aerating and weeding. The Garden C...
Overstock.com

$38.99

+$2.95 shipping