|
|
|
Comment |
Sorted by
Date Written |
Re: good, opinionative review, but make sure the facts are there (Reply to this comment)
by lambchops
Thank you--I hope I made it clear that I'm not a huge fan. I have a total of four or five of their albums, most of which I haven't purchased but that have been given to me. I appreciate the corrections.
Shelly.
|
Mar 31 '07
4:48 am PDT
|
|
good, opinionative review, but make sure the facts are there (Reply to this comment)
by dividedguy
First of all, good review. You don't have to be a huge Phish fan to write a good review, but be careful when talking about who's singing what. You mentioned that "My Friend My Friend" was instrumental, but only the intro is. There's a huge vocal element in that song. Also, you mentioned that TREY sings silent in the morning, but it's mainly Page that sings. I don't mean to be over-critical, but you might want to make sure the facts are there before making an honest review. Good job otherwise.
|
Mar 30 '07
6:15 pm PDT
|
|
eat them up, num (Reply to this comment)
by voxpoptart
My first encounter with Phish, a few years back, was when a cute girl at an airport lent me her headphones so i could hear one of their 15-minute live songs. I thought "Hm! This is much more interesting than i would've expected!", but i didn't buy their album, although i probably would've if the girl in question had lived anywhere near me.
Since then i've heard some of their studio stuff, which i also tend to like, but what i find interesting is that their best studio work (including Rift) doesn't even _try_ to sound like their live act. I'm sorry to hear that their live album isn't a good capture of their live experience, but in that case they deserve extra-special credit for just deciding "Okay then: while we're making records, we'll be someone else for awhile, someone who knows how to make records". It's oddly humble of them, and nifty. (Excellent review, btw!)
cheers,
- Brian
|
Dec 04 '04
10:44 pm PST
|
|
billy breathes (Reply to this comment)
by redsox75
You should check out their above entitled album as well. Though a big fan, I haven't picked Rift up yet. Maybe I can find it in the bargain bin. Meanwhile, check out Billy Breathes and you may change your mind as to what was Phish's best effort.
Drew
|
Dec 04 '04
8:17 am PST
|
|
From another non-Phish-head (Reply to this comment)
by chad8246
So many of my friends were big into Phish and while I never got into them I enjoyed the live shows that I saw. However, their albums just never "spoke" to me or even my die hard friends. Sure, they owned them all, but I can't ever remember them in their cars or cd players.
Bootleg tapes are another story.
Great stuff as always.
-Chad
|
Dec 02 '04
1:53 pm PST
|
|
|
|
© 1999-2009 Shopping.com, Inc.