Dirty Harry

22 ratings (22 Epinions reviews)
Epinions Product Rating: Excellent
5 stars
11
4 stars
11
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

It's Society's Fault

Jan 4, 2002
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review
  • User Rating: Excellent

  • Action Factor:
  • Suspense:

Pros:Eastwood, tight direction by Siegel, tension, action

Cons:Tries a bit too hard

The Bottom Line: Not as fascist as some believe, this movie entertains in ways that todays action films could never hope to


Plot Details: This opinion reveals major details about the movie's plot.

Well known, and much loved, Pauline Kael was one of the most important film critics ever to wield a pen. She called Dirty Harry "cheerfully fascist". I couldn't disagree more strongly with Ms. Kael's opinion. But more on that later.

The 1970's were a magic time. It was the last golden age of cinema. Barriers were being broken, new styles were being created, new voices were emerging, and movies were changing. Amidst all this excitement, even action movies underwent changes. The anti-hero, the Dionysian character, flawed, and hollow, jumped to the fore. Harry Callahan was the epitome of this new breed of movie protagonist. Had Clint Eastwood (Fist Full of Dollars, Unforgiven) not taken the role, one could easily imagine Steve Mcqueen in it.

Harry is a cop "on the edge", as the cliche goes. He's filled with anger, rage, sorrow for his dead wife, fear for the future of his city, and distrust of anyone different from him.

His strong arm tactics are right out of Chicago in the twenties. He likes to shoot first, and maybe not ask questions at all. He beats confessions out of "perps". In Harry's world there are no suspects. Everyone is guilty.

The city is being stalked by a madman. The film seems to suggest that the killer is only slightly more mad than the cop chasing him. This sniper threatens to kill one person per day, until the city gives in and pays him to stop.

When Harry gets close to catching him, the killer kidnaps a young girl, and tries to ransom her back.

The final act occurs after Harry catches the killer, and sees him released due to the illeagal, and brutal techniques employed to capture him.

Of course, that is merely the plot. The real story lies in the action, which is truly unrelenting. The pace of this film (as well as some of its specifics) would be re-used again and again by directors attempting to emulate its success.

Back to where we started. Pauline Kael saw Harry as a hero to a certain, slightly twisted, sort of American Male. She thought that the film espoused the lead character's belief system. In this, she was wrong. A close viewing of the movie shows that Siegel (the director) takes no political stance. In fact, the film goes to some extreme to show Harry in a poor light. And to suggest that cops like him (who certainly exist) cause more crime, by allowing the criminals to escape prosecution.

This film has no position, other than to entertain. In that aim, it succeeds beautifully.


Recommend this product? Yes


Viewing Format: DVD
Video Occasion: Fit for Friday Evening


Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!


Related Deals You Might Like...

Dirty Harry Collection DVD

Dirty Harry Collection DVD

Dirty Harry fans are bound to feel lucky when they pick up this collection of five action flicks featuring the iconic rogue cop who always gets his ma...
Family Video

$25.99

+$1.99 shipping
Dirty Harry Collection (blu-ray)

Dirty Harry Collection (blu-ray)

Dirty Harry fans are bound to feel lucky when they pick up this collection of five action flicks featuring the iconic rogue cop who always gets his ma...
eBay

$46.06

FREE Shipping
Dirty Harry (dvd, 1997)

Dirty Harry (dvd, 1997)

A tremendously controversial film, both decried as an apologia for fascism and hailed as the solution to a decade of rising crime, DIRTY HARRY propell...
eBay

$5.99

+$3.00 shipping
Dirty Harry (1971)
Walmart.com

$2.99

FREE Shipping
DIRTY HARRY/MAGNUM FORCE

DIRTY HARRY/MAGNUM FORCE

DIRTY HARRY/MAGNUM FORCE SKU: CHEV28940844
Sears Marketplace
Dirty Harry Collection Dvd Set Brand

Dirty Harry Collection Dvd Set Brand

Dirty Harry fans are bound to feel lucky when they pick up this collection of five action flicks featuring the iconic rogue cop who always gets his ma...
eBay

$25.99

+$4.99 shipping
The Dirty Harry Collection [dvd] [canadian] - Dvd

The Dirty Harry Collection [dvd] [canadian] - Dvd

Dirty Harry fans are bound to feel lucky when they pick up this collection of five action flicks featuring the iconic rogue cop who always gets his ma...
eBay

$29.49

+$2.99 shipping
Dirty Harry Deluxe Edition DVD

Dirty Harry Deluxe Edition DVD

A tremendously controversial film both decried as an apologia for fascism and hailed as the solution to a decade of rising crime DIRTY HARRY propelled...
Family Video

$8.99

+$1.99 shipping
Dirty Harry (vhs, 1993, Spanish Subtitled)

Dirty Harry (vhs, 1993, Spanish Subtitled)

A tremendously controversial film, both decried as an apologia for fascism and hailed as the solution to a decade of rising crime, DIRTY HARRY propell...
eBay

$5.99

FREE Shipping