Overview

Ageing and the generation gap are topics for humor and for tragedy. In Kotch, (1971) we have it both ways. It is a comedy, but not the backslapping, rib tickling kind. It is also a drama filled with tragedy, but not the gut wrenching, sobbing kind. The film is filled with subtlety, and it demands the viewers close attention to expressions, mannerisms, and voice tone.

Jack Lemmon and Walther Mattheu were an acting pair so often that they almost seem inseparable. In Kotch the relationship changes. Lemmon directs, and it was his only film as director. He appears only briefly as a sleeping bus passenger. Mattheu is the star, and he obviously takes his friend’s direction perfectly. Jack Lemmon’s wife, Felicia Farr, plays the daughter-in-law, Wilma Kotcher. The film is very well made in every way. Yet, its very subtlety suggests a focused audience. Those who do not appreciate these generation issues will not enjoy either the comedy or the tragedy.

One irony is that, although it is available on VHS, it is currently only on DVD coded for Europe.

The Story

“Kotch,” an elderly man, is staying with his son and daughter-in-law as the film opens. He is fully enjoying being with his grandchild, but there is friction between Kotch and the child’s mother. Kotch exhibits habits and mannerisms not compatible with the lifestyle and attitudes of his son and especially Wilma. That domestic scene is charming and also filled with conflict. Kotch works hard to discourage babysitters from being hired, and he tries to protect his grandchild from them when they are around.

One thing leads to another until Kotch is taken to a “retirement home” as a place where he can really enjoy life. Of course, that is not at all acceptable to him, and he takes off. The rest of the story is wonderfully unpredictable, and it takes twists and turns beyond anything you might expect. He even gets one of those babysitters to move in with him. Needless to say, Kotch makes contacts with people of other generations and interacts with them differently than he did at home.

Throughout the film, Kotch acts in ways that are in conflict with his environment, but he is constantly sincere. One example is his effort to fit in and honor the traditions of ethnic restaurants by using a few words other than English. He uses German in an Italian restaurant, Spanish in a Swiss restaurant, and French in a Mexican restaurant.

Filmmaking

Kotch is a low-budget film that produces more enjoyment than most which cost millions more. Lemmon’s directing is superb. He keeps things fresh and interesting while allowing Matthau to fully express the old man who has forgotten more than those around him have learned. The first section sets the stage for the drama to follow; some may not appreciate the need for that.

Walter Matthau was nominated for an Oscar, and his performance here certainly shows why. At the time, he was 51 years old, but he plays a man of 75 or so in a convincing way. Supporting actors are also excellent.

The film’s score is pleasant and contributes to the comforting mood of the production.



Recommended:
Yes

Viewing Format: VHS
Video Occasion: Better than Watching TV
Suitability For Children: Not suitable for Children of any age