Return of the Jedi

54 ratings (52 Epinions reviews)
Epinions Product Rating: Excellent
5 stars
30
4 stars
16
3 stars
4
2 stars
1
1 star
1
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

The Circle Is Complete... well, one third of it is

May 18, 2006 (Updated May 29, 2006)
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review
  • User Rating: Excellent

  • Action Factor:
  • Special Effects:
  • Suspense:

Pros:Plenty of action and adventure, Luke's battle with the Dark Side...

Cons:Loses some of the zest of the previous films, too much reliance on uninteresting creatures

The Bottom Line: Still a good film, but Return of the Jedi is the weakest of the original Star Wars trilogy.


Plot Details: This opinion reveals major details about the movie's plot.

Return of the Jedi is the final part of the original Star Wars trilogy (before they started doing the prequels). It does seem a bit strange that parts 4, 5, and 6 of a saga would be considered a trilogy, but that seems to be how creator George Lucas envisaged it – three distinct story arcs each covering 3 episodes, with am main thread tying them all together. (Not sure about who the characters were planned to be for the as yet unmade, purportedly never to be made episodes 7-9, but a few characters manage to appear in all 6 episodes so far.)

The first trilogy covered the arc of the creation of Darth Vader, the major villain of the piece in Episode 4 (Star Wars) and 5 (The Empire Strikes Back). The story arc covered in 4,5, and 6 is that of Luke Skywalker’s training to become a Jedi Knight, learn to use the Force (a mystical energy field surrounding everything), and defeat the Empire, with it’s mega-evil Emperor and Darth Vader.

In the original Star Wars, the Rebel Alliance, of which Luke becomes a member, has to destroy the Death Star, an immensely powerful weapon that would make the Empire all-powerful. Thwarted by the Alliance back then, the Empire starts making a new one, protected by an energy field – thus impervious to attack by space ships. The Alliance must find a way to get through that shield…

However, before we get to that there’s some serious Jedi handiwork to be done as Han Solo, roguish mercenary and now galactic hero, is frozen as a decoration for Jabba the Hutt at the beginning of the film. The Hutts are a very rich race of very large slugs, who surround themselves with strange creatures of an equally unpleasant disposition to themselves. Cue one rescue mission – that doesn’t quite go as intended…


… and plenty of other heroics, action sequences, small green wrinkly things muttering on about the Force, and more revelations about the family Skywalker. Romance has blossomed between Han Solo and Princess Leia, though certain things threaten to come between them… Small annoying creatures called Ewoks are to be found on the Sanctuary Moon of Endor (thanks AlexDG1 for the galactic geography correction!), but they’re not quite the teddy bears they resemble…


There, I think I’ve given you a flavour of the storyline while hopefully not giving too much away for the 1% of the world’s population who doesn’t already know it off by heart. There are action scenes and space battles in plentiful abundance, and quite a bit of humour though not as much as the previous 2 episodes. A key aspect of the storyline is Luke Skywalker’s battle as he tries to resist turning to the Dark Side of the Force. This is played out in an interesting way alongside a duel, and is paralleled by another character’s inward fight to turn to the Light Side of the Force. Meanwhile, Sole, Leia, and some other characters are finding out just how annoying the Ewoks are. Apart from a certain lack of gusto in the performances overall, it is over-reliance on creatures – not just the Ewoks – that make this film the weakest of the original trilogy. (Whereas if truth be told the underlying themes in the plot are probably more involving than either Star Wars or The Empire Strikes Back.) While the action and adventure are still there, the special effects are still great, and the music is as good as ever, the spark that lit the imagination of millions with the first two films just isn’t quite there in Return of the Jedi.

That’s not to say that it isn’t an enjoyable film though. Mark Hamill fighting the lure of the Dark Side is pretty compelling, and while Solo and Leia’s romance did (like many of the relationships in this particular film) seem just a bit too conveniently cosy for much of the film, there is a scene where it becomes a bit more dramatic nearer the end. Richard Marquand took the helm as Director this time and didn’t seem to know quite what mood he wanted to take with this film – the cheerful exuberance of Star Wars of the darker, brooding atmosphere of Empire Strikes back. The film appears to veer between the two extremes, but somehow lacks balance in key scenes. Maybe it’s a bit of an age thing too – when I first saw it at the cinema as a child all those years ago (ahem… not all that many years ago!), I really didn’t like it much. Seeing it on TV a few years later though, I did start to appreciate it more. Nowadays I view it as a satisfying end to the original trilogy, but not as good as the first two movies.


(Tried to resist mentioning it but failed... some people might think that seeing Princess Leia (Carrie Fisher) in a particular outfit in this film is reason enough to watch it... but I'm saying nothing!!)

Other Information

Year of release: 1983
Length: 134 minutes
Rating: PG f


At the time of writing this review, Return of the Jedi was listed at #110 in IMDB’s all-time top 250 movies list with an average score of 8.2

The Empire Strikes Back was #8 with an average rating of 8.8

Star Wars was #10 with the same average rating.

Revenge of the Sith weighed in at #207 with an average rating of 8.0

Attack of the Clones managed an average rating of 6.9, while Phantom Menace got 6.4. People must have been being kind to them!



More Star Wars Reviews

Films

Star Wars Episode III – Revenge of the Sith

Star Wars Episode VI: A New Hope

Star Wars Episode V: The Empire Strikes Back


Animated

The Clone Wars Volume 1
The Clone Wars Volume 2

Computer Games:

Jedi Academy from the Jedi Knights series, published by LucasArts.

Knights of the Old Republic, also by LucasArts, the first real attempt at a Star Wars RPG.


See also my Top Ten Science Fiction Films of All Time



Recommend this product? Yes


Video Occasion: Good for a Rainy Day

Read all comments (2)

Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!


Related Deals You Might Like...

Return of the Jedi (Star Wars)

Return of the Jedi (Star Wars)

Luke Skywalker leads the Rebel Alliance in a bold attempt to overcome the evil power of Darth Vader and the Empire
Sears
Star Wars Return Of The Jedi Micro Machines Space

Star Wars Return Of The Jedi Micro Machines Space

NEW IN BOX- STAR WARS - RETURN OF THE JEDI- MICRO MACHINES - SPACE THE ORIGINAL SCALE MINIATURES AGES 4 + COLLECTORS EDITION COLLECTORS NUMBER 014679 ...
eBay

$29.99

+$6.00 shipping
Star Wars Hardback Return Of The Jedi 1983 Nice Condition With Photos

Star Wars Hardback Return Of The Jedi 1983 Nice Condition With Photos

ravensnest store STAR WARS HARDBACK RETURN OF THE JEDI 1983 NICE CONDITION WITH PHOTOS YOU ARE BIDDING ON STAR WARS HARDBACK RETURN OF THE JEDI 1983 N...
eBay

$19.99

FREE Shipping
Star Wars Return Of The Jedi At-st Driver 12 Inch Figure Sealed

Star Wars Return Of The Jedi At-st Driver 12 Inch Figure Sealed

LOW PRICE! FAST SERVICE! GREAT COMBINED SHIPPING RATES! This listing is for one (1)2002 STAR WARS RETURN OF THE JEDI 12-INCH AT-ST DRIVER figure by Ha...
eBay

$74.99

+$12.75 shipping
Star Wars Return Of The Jedi Deck Protector Card Sleeves 50ct Limited Edition

Star Wars Return Of The Jedi Deck Protector Card Sleeves 50ct Limited Edition

Star Wars RETURN OF THE JEDI Deck Protector Card Sleeves 50ct Limited Edition You are looking at a brand new factory sealed pack of Star Wars Deck Pro...
eBay

$6.50

FREE Shipping
Star Wars ''Return of the Jedi'' Figure Play Set

Star Wars ''Return of the Jedi'' Figure Play Set

Luke Skywalker in Jedi costume Princess Leia in slave costume C-3PO Jabba the Hut Gamorrean Guard Bib Fortuna
Sears
Star Wars return Of The Jedi 1983 Record Sealed

Star Wars return Of The Jedi 1983 Record Sealed

Star Wars Vintage 1983 Record Available for purchase is (1) Vintage 1983 Star Wars Return of the Jedi (ROTJ) 24-page Read-along book and Record, 33 1/...
eBay

$6.29

+$3.99 shipping
Star Wars Return Of The Jedi Metal Promo P3 Card From 1995 Metallic Impressions

Star Wars Return Of The Jedi Metal Promo P3 Card From 1995 Metallic Impressions

You are buying an Star Wars Metallic Impressions 1995 Return of the Jedi Promo card P3. This card is brand new and is the item pictured. PAYMENT SHIPP...
eBay

$8.99

+$2.99 shipping
Return of the Jedi (Star Wars Trilogy)

Return of the Jedi (Star Wars Trilogy)

Relates the attempted rescue of Han Solo by Luke Skywalker and his companions and the final confrontation between Darth Vader and the Rebel Alliance.
Sears
Star Wars Luke Skywalker Jedi Knight Cold-Cast Statue

Star Wars Luke Skywalker Jedi Knight Cold-Cast Statue

He's a Jedi, like his father before him. One of the largest Luke Skywalker representations ever! Limited edition statue comes with a certificate of au...
EntertainmentEarth.com

$444.99

+$48.95 shipping