No Regrets for Our Youth

1 ratings (1 Epinions review)
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

Kurosawa's one female-centered movie

Mar 14, 2006 (Updated Oct 7, 2009)
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review
  • User Rating: Very Good

  • Action Factor:
  • Suspense:

Pros:Hara Setusko in a physically and emotionally demanding role

Cons:boring first hour and overwrought second

The Bottom Line: A very unusual Japanese movie from 1946 that needs subtitling by someone who understands English (and a better video transfer).


Plot Details: This opinion reveals major details about the movie's plot.

"Waga Seishun ni Kuinashi" (No Regrets for Our Youth) is more interesting as a phenomenon than enjoyable as a film. What makes it interesting:

(1) Released in 1946, tt is arguably the first major film directed by Akira Kurosawa. It is, without doubt, his first postwar movie, and

(2) one of the first Japanese movies passing the censors of the US ("Allied") occupation of Japan, which is all the more striking, because,

(3) it celebrates a leftist opponent of militarism and fascism during the early 1930s. That the MacArthur regime permitted commemoration of what appears to be (but is named as) a communist is outright startling.

(4) The movie is the closest to be an autobiographical film by Kurosawa (up until his last, Madadayo). Kurosawa was a leftist opponent of the fascist militarism of the 1930s, and shocked his parents by first becoming an art student and then undertaking an entry-level job in the film industry. (The autobiographical component is limited in that the movie focuses on a female student who shocks everyone by going to work as a peasant with the parents after he is killed in police custody.)

(5) The film focuses on a woman, unlike any other Kurosawa film.

(6) The actress in the lead role is Hara Setusko , closely associated (by appearing in many movies directed by) Ozu (though also memorable in Kurosawa's adaptation of The Idiot). The mother-in-law is also played by Ozu regular Sugimura Haruko. (And, although the camerawork is fluid, many shots are from angles even lower than Ozu's camera setup.)

(7) Shimura Takashi was already in the Kurosawa repertory company (and in many, many other Kurosawa movies, with the biggest parts being in "Ikiru," "The Drunken Angel," and "Seven Samurai").

(8) The influence of prewar Soviet cinema, particularly Eisensteinian montage and treatment of seething crowds, is very obvious, along with some Dovzhenko agrarian romanticism (particularly characters lying down, looking at the sky, and the blurred farm labor sequences, especillay Yukie staggering along carrying a basket).

The DVD about which I originally epined had absurd and often unreadable subtitles over a poor print. The Criterion "Postwar Kurosawa" Eclipse release remedied these two problmes. The remaining one, which is Kurosawa's fault, is that the first hour is boring: very talky with only a few interesting visual touches (the piano playing and the montages of Yukie (Hara) and of Tokyo, when she moves there. *Yea, yeah, I'll provide some plot summary eventually...)

It was an effort of will to get through the first hour—in which idealistic young students are shocked when Yukie's father is not allowed to lecture any more at their university (ca. 1933 Kyoto), and there is a triangular relationship between Yukie and two of the students (who look like cadets in their uniforms). Yet another strangeness of the subtitles is that Noge, the bespectacled zealot (played by Fujita Susumu), and Itokawa, the more pragmatic (and eventually mustachioed) suitor of Yuki and friend of Noge (played by Kôno Akitake) are called "Wild" and "Hun."

Noge comes to dinner with Itokawa, Yukie, and his parents (after the school has been shut down altogether and the student groups banned) and says he is going off to China (the just-conquered Manchuria). Yukie has something of a mad scene and decides to move to Tokyo. After the passage of a few years, she runs into Itokawa and meets Noge again. Both are successful in financial institutions of some sort. Yukie is a sort of economic analyst.

After they marry, Itokawa is seized in a restaurant by Police Commissioner "Poison Strawberry" Dokuichigo (Shimura). This and the following scenes of Dokuichigo sneering (Shimura was so good at that!) and interrogating Yukie bring the movie to life (very fraught life, but not longer boring).

Noge dies (offscreen) in police custody and is posthumously branded as being a spy. Yukie is released, plays the piano in obvious hysteria, and decides to go live with Noge's parents, peasants whom she has never met. They are, not surprisingly, discomfited to have a city girl on their hands, but Yukie throws herself into tilling the fields in ways that would have made Maoists happy when they emptied the universities to "re-educate" students during the 1960s.

Hara is impressive in playing the young woman determined to make herself a model peasant daughter-in-law. The project seems crazy to me, but apparently seemed virtuous to Japanese. It is definitely cinematic and includes some signature Kurosawa scenes of slogging through the mud and heavy rain...

In a rushed coda after Japan loses the war, Noge and Yukie's father are rehabilitated and honored. Yukie, both in the fields, and restored to upper middle-class life, regularly repeats Noge's mantra "No regrets in my life, no regrets whatsoever"—which also seems to me borderline crazy, in that he was tortured to death and Yukie suffered greatly as the wife of a much-maligned "spy" (etc.!).

Hara is convincing aging some twenty years, slogging through the rice paddies and destroying her pianist hands. She could do much more than Ozu ever asked her to do! Both Yukie and Noge anticipate the long line of Kurosawa individualists (often embodied by Mifune Toshiro), refusing to do what others expect them to do.

For me, the first great Kurosawa movie is "Drunken Angel" (1948), which teamed Shimura and Kurosawa (as, respectively, a slum doctor and a tubercular, alcoholic gangster). It also had much social commentary about it (and sympathy for slum-dwellers trying to get along). There are some striking scenes and sequences in the second hour of "No Regrets," but getting that far is a daunting challenge, and the bewilderment induced by the titles recurs (though there are long stretches of working the fields with no talk to mangle in translation in that last third of the movie).

Kurosawa told Donald Richie that the story of Noge was inspired by a real-life case (Ozaki Hidemi), but that he was asked to leave the subject to a younger director, so had to substitute the second half. This is disconcerting in that I think the second half is much the better one! (The fired professor is based on the firing of Takikawa Yukitoki from the University of Kyoto faculty in 1933, and Ozaki was a student of Professor Takikawa, outraged by his dismissal.)

Less disconcerting is Kurosawa's memory that he "believed that the only way for Japan to make a new start was to begin respecting the 'self' [instead of the usual submission to expectations and the group/family). "I wanted to show a woman who did just that." In this, he definitely succeeded (though I vigorously dissent from Richie's claim that the movie is "perfect"). Kurosawa also told Richie that "it was only here and in 'Rashomon' that I ever fairly and fully portrayed a woman... [one who] lived by and was true to her feelings." As Richie notes, Kuorsawa showed this "sternly and uncompromisingly."

---

In addition to the longer-ago historical movies Kurosawa went on to direct (Rashômon, Seven Samurai, Throne of Blood, Yojimbo, Sanjuro, Red Beard, Kagemusha, Ran), Kurosawa made a number of socially conscious movies about postwar Japan, of which my favorites Drunken Angel, Stray Dog, Ikiru, High and the Low; the available DVD of The Bad Sleep Well is plagued with  transfer and subtitle problems). I have also recommended the documentary biography Kurosawa.

�2006, Stephen O. Murray




Recommend this product? No


Viewing Format: DVD
Suitability For Children: Not suitable for Children of any age

Read all comments (7)

Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!


Related Deals You Might Like...

Nitro Youth Girls Wee Regret Ins Snowboard Pants Med Teal

Nitro Youth Girls Wee Regret Ins Snowboard Pants Med Teal

You are bidding on a new pair of Girl's Nitro Wee Regret Insulated Snowboard Pants in size Medium. US 9-10 Youth EUR 140 Color is Dark Teal. Mini vers...
eBay

$63.96

FREE Shipping
CafePress No Regrets3 Light T-Shirt

CafePress No Regrets3 Light T-Shirt

Shop Today! Get Extra 20% OFF! Use code CSE20! Classic T-Shirt100% preshrunk cotton, Ash Grey is a 90/10 Cotton/Poly Blend6.1 ozTagless, Crew Neckline...
CafePress.com

$16.99

+$6.49 shipping
2014 Nitro Girls Regret Ins Snowboard Pants Medium Aqua Youth

2014 Nitro Girls Regret Ins Snowboard Pants Medium Aqua Youth

For sale is a new with tags pair of Girl's Nitro Regret Insulated Snowboard Pants in size Medium. US 9-10 Youth EUR 140 Color is Aqua.One of our best ...
eBay

$97.46

FREE Shipping
Kinetix black cotton 'No Regrets' printed t-shirt

Kinetix black cotton 'No Regrets' printed t-shirt

Kinetix black cotton 'No Regrets' printed t-shirt. Lightweight cotton jersey knit - available in Black. 100% Cotton. 60 Day Return Policy
Bluefly

$18.00

+$7.95 shipping
No Regrets Photo: Bella Flowy Boxy Crop Top T-Shirt

No Regrets Photo: Bella Flowy Boxy Crop Top T-Shirt

No regrets? Never. Live life and don't look back. Be trendy with this tumblr inspired photo quote design! One of the biggest problems in customizable...
Customized Girl

$24.97

FREE Shipping
Guys Steadfast Never Regret Tee

Guys Steadfast Never Regret Tee

Here's to regret -free tattoos! Steadfast Never Regret cotton tee featuring front text and rear brand logo graphic. Available only online at Journeys....
Journeys

$20.00

FREE Shipping
Nanette Lepore No Regrets Dress (Ivory Multi) Women's Dress Size MD

Nanette Lepore No Regrets Dress (Ivory Multi) Women's Dress Size MD

You did it before and you'll do it again in this goddess No Regrets dress! ; Mixed media print throughout creates a complementary tribal-inspired look...
Zappos.com

$298.00

FREE Shipping
Said No One Ever: I Regret That Workout Racerback

Said No One Ever: I Regret That Workout Racerback

Women's Racerback Tank Top 100% cotton jersey Standard fit Machine wash cold, tumble dry low
Cafepress.com

$26.50

+$6.49 shipping
2012 Nitro Youth Girls Regret Ins Snowboard Pants Medium Gray

2012 Nitro Youth Girls Regret Ins Snowboard Pants Medium Gray

You are bidding on a new with tags pair of Girl's Nitro Regret Insulated Snowboard Pants in size Medium. US 9-10 Youth EUR 140 Color is Storm. One of ...
eBay

$68.22

FREE Shipping
CafePress No Regrets2 Jr. Jersey T-Shirt

CafePress No Regrets2 Jr. Jersey T-Shirt

Shop Today! Get Extra 20% OFF! Use code CSE20! Junior Jersey T-Shirt4.3 oz. 100% ultra-fine combed ring-spun jerseyMade in the USA, by American Appare...
CafePress.com

$20.99

+$6.49 shipping