Christmas Carol Reviews

Christmas Carol

7 consumer reviews |Write a Review
Average Rating: Excellent
5 stars
7
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

Where Can I Buy It?Compare all Prices

$2.10 Amazon Marketplace Lowest Price
Read all 7 Reviews | Write a Review

About the Author

carstairs38
Epinions.com ID: carstairs38
Member: Mark Baker
Location: Sunny Southern CA
Reviews written: 1989
Trusted by: 171 members
About Me: Aiming for 12 races in 2012.

If You Only See One Version of A Christmas Carol, Make It This One

Written: Nov 08 '07 (Updated Nov 07 '09)
  • User Rating: Excellent
  • Special Effects:
Pros:Seriously, everything
Cons:Not a thing
The Bottom Line: You can look all you want, but you won't find any version better then this one.

Plot Details: This opinion reveals minor details about the movie's plot.

From my mom, I have inherited a love of Charles Dickens's story A Christmas Carol. Every December, I enjoy it in a couple of different forms. I have even watched some of the recent modern takes on the story, and mostly enjoyed them. But if I am looking for a serious film interpretation of the book, I look no further then this 1984 made for TV movie.

The story told here has literally been told countless times on stage and screen. Ebenezer Scrooge (George C. Scott) is a miserable miser who desires nothing more then money. He has no friends, pinches every penny, abuses his poor clerk (David Warner), and won't even consider giving to the poor.

One Christmas Eve, he is haunted by four spirits who attempt to show him the error of his ways by showing him his past, present, and future. Is there any hope for Scrooge? If there is, will they get through to him?

Now I will admit my biases to this film up front. I have seen it just about every Christmas since it first aired. Yet I think this truly is a great film version. For starters, it sticks very close to the original novella. While not a deal breaker, the fact that they tried to be faithful really enhances my love for it. There are a couple minor changes, but nothing to get upset about. Yet this doesn't make the movie boring. It moves from one scene to another quickly. Just a few seconds are enough to get my glued to my seat for the remainder of the film.

Then there is the look of the movie. One glance and you are easily transported to 1800's London. The sets and costumes are beautiful and authentic. The special effects are impressive, even by today's standards.

And we can't leave out the acting. The only possible bad note is Anthony Walters who seems a little stiff in his first scene as Tiny Tim. And I feel like a grump for pointing that out because everything else is wonderful. Everyone hits all the right notes, and by the time I am done I feel like I have been on the same emotional journey with Scrooge.

One word of warning for parents. The scenes leading up to the appearance of Marley's Ghost could be scary for young kids. I will admit those scenes still give me chills, and used to scare me every year, even as an early teen. My younger brother, on the other hand, never had a problem with it. Nothing else about this tale should be that scary, but you might want to preview it and judge it against your kid's reactions to things yourself.

The DVD is a bare bones release. While some extras would have been nice, they certainly weren't necessary. The picture and sound are sharp, which is amazing for a 20 year old film. They certainly look better then the copy I taped off TV.

If you want to find a film version of A Christmas Carol, look no further. It is sure to become a family Christmas tradition.

This is a Lean 'n Mean entry in CaptainD's Good Film Write-Off

Recommended: Yes


Viewing Format: DVD

Read all comments (2)|Write your own comment
Read all 7 Reviews | Write a Review

Share with your friends   
Share This!


Where can I buy it?
Showing 1-4 of 5 deals
Fantastic prices with ease & c...
Christmas elicits nothing more than "Bah, humbug!" from Ebenezer Scrooge (Scott), a miser whose sole pursuit of financial success has left him a bitte...
Amazon Marketplace
Store Rating: 3.0
Fantastic prices with ease & c...
Christmas elicits nothing more than "Bah, humbug!" from Ebenezer Scrooge (Scott), a miser whose sole pursuit of financial success has left him a bitte...
Amazon Marketplace
Store Rating: 3.0
Earn 2% eBay Bucks on qualifyi...
Filmed in Shrewsbury, England, this version of Dickens' beloved classic is considered by many to be the best. All the performances are excellent, but ...
eBay
Store Rating: 4.0

Free Shipping
Filmed in Shrewsbury England this version of Dickens' beloved classic is considered by many to be the best. All the performances are excellent but Geo...
Family Video
Store Rating: 4.5
View More Deals       Why are these stores listed?