Titanic

438 ratings (392 Epinions reviews)
Epinions Product Rating: Very Good
5 stars
185
4 stars
64
3 stars
53
2 stars
44
1 star
46
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

"Titanic" or bust?

Mar 4, 2001 (Updated Mar 18, 2001)
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review
  • User Rating: Excellent

  • Action Factor:
  • Special Effects:
  • Suspense:

Pros:Great special effects!

Cons:Weak love story.

The Bottom Line: A good film with amazing special effects. The story is good but the romance is weak...


Plot Details: This opinion reveals minor details about the movie's plot.

"Titanic" is a competently produced and directed film about one of the most romantic and mystic disasters of the twentieth century. I've always argued that I hope no one ever makes a picture about Titanic, because one day I will. But now I won't have to, because James Cameron beat me to the punch.

Cameron sets the movie up by placing it in the present on an exploration vessel that is visiting the wreckage. The explorers are searching for buried treasure, the "Hope Diamond" that is probably worth a ton of money. But it's through their search that the audience meets an elderly lady who says she was on Titanic, who says she knows about the coveted diamond. So she's brought along and specifically, it's through her that we learn about Titanic's story.

Staring Leonardo DiCaprio and Kate Winslet, director James Cameron takes us on a journey into the past, showing us the Titanic in all its glory through these two young eyes.

DiCaprio is a third class passenger, who wins his ticket in a card game. Winslet is the beautiful first class damsel in distress, who is unfortunately doomed to marry a spoilt idiot. But love prevails and these two meet and have fun. Of course it's a tragic love story, as we all know what will happen in the end.

But the romance feels sloppy, almost as if it's just running through the motions. It lacks the powerhouse feelings that one gets when they watch a true romance story, such as "The Bridges of Madison County," or "Greese." But overall it's played fairly well. The important point is that Cameron is trying to create enough reality between their situation and the emotions of the audience, so that when the disaster strikes, we're emotional babies. In some ways it sounds manipulative, but it works here to a degree.

Another credit to Cameron was his smart computer recreation of the sinking we see at the beginning of the film on board the exploration vessel. That way near the end of the film when the disaster strikes, we know exactly how the ship is going to sink. And we also know where the characters shouldn't be running during the escape.

But for me, it wasn't really through the relationship that I felt like I was sinking with the ship. It was through a few other minor characters that I was able to gain a strong connection to the ship. And to be honest I would have liked to have seen more of them. Specifically, I'd like to have seen more of Titanic's Captain, eventually left alone on his bridge as the waters explode through the windows. And the designer / architect of the Titanic, sailing on her maiden voyage, trapped bravely in the dinning room as his ship sinks. Seeing the expressions of disappointment on these men's faces, that was what moved me.

The effects of the sinking are wonderful. Watching it break in two and fall back down into the water was breath-taking moment. I really felt like I was sinking with the ship. It truly was "epic," to say the least.

But my only other wish (with the first one being a better romance and more secondary characters), would have been to see more of the ship. A few nights earlier, I had watched an A&E documentary, and the Titanic was much larger than we saw in the movie. Did you know it had two large swimming pools, and a slew of other areas that would have been wonderful to see on the big screen? Sadly though, I saw more of the Titanic on the A&E Special than in the movie. But that doesn't mean the movie isn't worth watching, because it is.

A lot of people I had talked to before it was released had their doubts about Titanic. One person said, "how can you make a movie about that?" And my reply was, "well, they made Schindler's List, didn't they?" I knew Titanic would do well, but not as well as it has.

But, deep down, I wish it was more. I wish the romance was more, I wish it moved me more, because I wanted to be moved to absolute tears. But I wasn't, and I guess for Cameron, this was as good as it could get. So maybe someday I will make my version after all.

Grade: B+

(Originally reviewed on December 30, 1997)


Recommend this product? Yes


Viewing Format: DVD
Video Occasion: Fit for Friday Evening
Suitability For Children: Suitable for Children Age 13 and Older

Read all comments (3)

Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!


Related Deals You Might Like...

Titanic Rose Barbie Doll

Titanic Rose Barbie Doll

Inspired by the multiple Academy AwardŽ-winning blockbuster film, Titanic BarbieŽ doll is a wonderful tribute to one of the most romantic movies ever ...
eBay

$129.99

+$5.80 shipping
Titanic Natural Wood Puzzle

Titanic Natural Wood Puzzle

Ready to take your 3D puzzle skills to the next level? This large Titanic Ship 3D Jigsaw Woodcraft Kit will meet that challenge! Made from a high grad...
Sears Marketplace
Titanic Natural Wood Puzzle

Titanic Natural Wood Puzzle

Ready to take your 3D puzzle skills to the next level? This large Titanic Ship 3D Jigsaw Woodcraft Kit will meet that challenge Made from a high grade...
Toys R Us

$17.99

+$7.99 shipping
Plastic Rms Titanic 1:570 Model Kit

Plastic Rms Titanic 1:570 Model Kit

Discover a love of nautical history and all things Titanic-related by collecting this small plastic model ship. The famous ship is depicted on a 1:570...
Overstock.com

$19.66

+$2.95 shipping
Titanic Ship 3D Puzzle - Jigsaw Woodcraft Kit Wooden Puzzle

Titanic Ship 3D Puzzle - Jigsaw Woodcraft Kit Wooden Puzzle

This Large Titanic Ship 3D Jigsaw Woodcraft Kit, is a high grade 3mm wooden puzzles come with assembly instructions. Designs are pre-cut. Contains 178...
Brilliant Puzzles

$11.95

+$3.20 shipping
Titanic Ship - 3D Jigsaw Woodcraft Kit Wooden Puzzle

Titanic Ship - 3D Jigsaw Woodcraft Kit Wooden Puzzle

This Large Titanic Ship 3D Jigsaw Woodcraft Kit, is a high grade 3mm wooden puzzles come with assembly instructions. Designs are pre-cut. Contains 71 ...
Zoom Puzzles
Mattel Barbie Titanic Doll - Pink Label - Collector 2007 - K8666 - Mint

Mattel Barbie Titanic Doll - Pink Label - Collector 2007 - K8666 - Mint

Inspired by the multiple Academy AwardŽ-winning blockbuster film, Titanic BarbieŽ doll is a wonderful tribute to one of the most romantic movies ever ...
eBay

$135.00

+$15.00 shipping
Plastic RMS Titanic 1:570 Model Kit

Plastic RMS Titanic 1:570 Model Kit

Discover a love of nautical history and all things Titanic-related by collecting this small plastic model ship. The famous ship is depicted on a 1:570...
Sears Marketplace
Titanic - 1000pc Jigsaw Puzzle by Eurographics

Titanic - 1000pc Jigsaw Puzzle by Eurographics

From a cross-section of the ship to the various stages of its sinking, this puzzle explores one of the most well known maritime tragedies in history. ...
Serious Puzzles

$17.95

+$6.00 shipping