|
Comment |
Sorted by
Date Written |
LotR is a page in cinematography (Reply to this comment)
by arashi-san
PJ and his wonderfully fanatic crew have created a true masterpiece. Even more so in the Special Extended Edition, I think. Their devotion to the job practically shines through. 'Lord of the Rings' is one of my all-time favorite movies (esp. 'The Fellowship'), and I thank you for the great review. Keep up the good job!
Cheers,
Arashi
|
Mar 21 '08
6:20 pm PDT
|
|
interesting take (Reply to this comment)
by iidays
on
"“The Ring is trying to get back to its
Comment Sorted by
Interesting take
female roles were miscast...interesting
Cons: took a little time.
Long movie that could have been longer.
Heres an apple link to trailer:
http://www.apple.com/trailers/newline/returnoftheking/
Thought you may also like an extra tale
" The Curse of Castle Doom"
http://www.btinternet.com/~albilcoproductions/tonystanley.htm
A Fantasy Novel By A Stanley
PS. A Thank you again to author "A Stanley"
Date Written Aug 31 '05
12:22 pm PDT
Comment: (Delete your comment?)
|
Aug 31 '05
1:44 pm PDT
|
|
Great review! (Reply to this comment)
by guohao
Your enthusiasm for the movie shone through...now I feel like watching the movie again! Agree with you on most parts of the review. I didn't quite like Galadriel but I thought Arwen was ok.
Chris
|
May 12 '05
1:24 am PDT
|
|
Nice job (Reply to this comment)
by wigwamstealer
Excellent review. I had to agree with you on just about everything, except for your dislike of the female casting. Personally, I thought Cate Blanchett's icy demeanor was perfect for the role, and Liv Tyler brought youthfulness, toughness, and grace ( all neccesary for an elf, lol ) to her role. Other than that, again, awesome job and keep it up.
|
Jan 10 '05
6:15 pm PST
|
|
Re: A Review Worthy of the Movie (Reply to this comment)
by brett_w
Greatpilgrim (and I love that name, although "Victoria" is pretty regal too), your review truly does justice to the movie. I distinctly remember staggering breathlessly out, and how distant and mundane the world felt as I drove home. I went back and re-read from "Hobbit" to "Silmarillian" afterword!
Your review captures those feelings.
Cheers, Brett
p.s. Borrowed last comment title because I was gonna use pretty much the same thing!
|
Jul 11 '03
1:47 pm PDT
|
|
A Review Worthy of the Movie (Reply to this comment)
by bilbopooh
Gorgeous review. It is clear that you are a true fan, as your profile attests as well. Nice job.
|
Jun 24 '03
6:58 pm PDT
|
|
Woah.... (Reply to this comment)
by jul_7_1989
This is a really good review. You covered all the aspects in a clear, detailed way. I loved your review and I actually agree with you with just about everything. I also think the movie is great! I really enjoyed you review, it was detailed and lively!!
Cheers,
jul_7
|
Mar 11 '03
5:02 pm PST
|
|
Dead on! (Reply to this comment)
by pduvall
This movie (and it's earlier chapter) are the only things since the books themselves which did not disappoint me.
It is, to the books, what TV is to radio.
|
Mar 06 '03
7:21 pm PST
|
|
I think... (Reply to this comment)
by Ahab1973
You're right on the money comparing it with the first of the original Star Wars films. It has that same feeling.
I usually hate these fantasy type movies but this one sucked me in and I thoroughly enjoyed it. Nice review too, BTW.
|
Aug 10 '02
1:35 am PDT
|
|
Rings (Reply to this comment)
by green1
As a LOTR newcomer, I am looking forward to "The Two Towers" this Winter, but I will not read the book. I want to be surprised to see what happens next.
Da Zvadanya, Tovarich....
|
Jul 31 '02
11:00 pm PDT
|
|
You're making me wish (Reply to this comment)
by msiduri
I had gone to see it again as I'd planned earlier today...
I'm ready to move into Rivendell, myself.
And yes, FRODO LIVES!
Marie
|
Feb 24 '02
3:38 pm PST
|
|
Re: Incredible Review!! (Reply to this comment)
by Greatpilgrim
SSHHHH!! I changed my picture because it's scary how much I look like that Liv Tyler picture. And I'm not a redhead like that old pic I had up there. But don't tell anyone my secret!
Victoria
|
Feb 24 '02
4:20 am PST
|
|
Incredible Review!! (Reply to this comment)
by grimjack2
Wow. You don't do a lot of movie reviews, but when you do... I am totally in envy of reading that you have had 246 member reads. You are approaching ptiemann levels of readership here!
You done a great job of explaining why it is you left the theater feeling the way you did. Your love of it really shined through in your words. I'm amazed you didn't describe the film as "my precious".
While I had no problem with Blanchet as the Elf Queen, I was a little bothered by Arwen. I have to ask why you've changed your profile picture to be of Liv Tyler when you didn't like her in the film either. I think they dubbed her voice or something, because it just didn't sound like her to me.
This is an excellent review, and I can see why you consider it to be your best.
|
Feb 22 '02
10:46 am PST
|
|
LOTR addict (Reply to this comment)
by trasjman
I went to the movie premiere in December 2001. I was totally stunned. Sat in my seat for 5 minutes before I got up.
Before I went I was a little apprehensive, because I read the book(s) for like 5 times and had my own images of Middle-earth. But when I saw the film, I had the feeling Peter Jackson stole my brain. Practically everything looked like I imagined it!
Some friends of mine were disappointed by the open ending. So I gave them my copy. Now they're asking me all the time when the next one will come to the theaters.
And your review was great as usual!
|
Feb 21 '02
4:58 am PST
|
|
Good (Reply to this comment)
by peterbryan
I thought that the movie was good, but it didn't satisfy me on the grand level I was expecting. I even had the courage to see it again but to the same effect. All in all, not too bad, but I wouldn't place it ahead of other movies much like it's kind.
|
Feb 11 '02
3:49 pm PST
|
|
The most amazing... (Reply to this comment)
by elomage
...part of the movie for me was the creation of all the fantastic worlds, down to the smallest details. And I know that it is not so easy even in these computer-ever-powerful times. A LOT of good work has been put in the movie, and that was the most stunning aspect for me.
Also, the movie was good for those not familiar with the book. My other half said the three hours were not enough. Now we have the book(s).
Very impressed with the movie and your reviews!
--L.
|
Feb 04 '02
7:50 pm PST
|
|
Complete Agreement! (Reply to this comment)
by ejanay
It's truly amazing how much I agree with your opinion. It's awesome! You can put into words what I can only think in my mind. I have to agree with the casting of the women. Even if they would have switched the roles, I think it would have been better. I cried at the same moments too! Anyhow, fabulous review! You have a gift with words!
|
Jan 09 '02
8:58 pm PST
|
|
Fantastic review! (Reply to this comment)
by serc
Oddly enough, the only preview we got in Northfield was to the next Austin Powers movie (how is that for a surreal combination?).
I agree with you about the Liv Tyler thing. Not that I have an ideal Arwen in my mind; it's just that she gives me flashbacks to Armageddon, and every time I see her face, I think of that lame song, "Cause I Miss You Babe, and I Don't Want to Miss a Thing...."
Excellent, on target review. I can't wait to see this movie again!
-Sara R-C
|
Jan 08 '02
8:19 pm PST
|
|
Re: Great review (Reply to this comment)
by luvrdaisy
The Arwen character was not created for the movie... she played a small role in the story itself, but if you look in the Appendix (at the end of "Return of the King") the entire story of her and Aragorn is present, minus the "heroine" aspect, which is the only thing added.
~LD
|
Jan 07 '02
10:11 am PST
|
|
Without doing too much (Reply to this comment)
by nagels
Tolkien, wanted to say I think this review is outstanding. Can't wait to see the movie.
|
Jan 03 '02
10:45 am PST
|
|
Re: hmm.. (Reply to this comment)
by Greatpilgrim
Are you kidding? There's three here! Viggo Mortenson is the obvious hottie, but then there's the very appealling Orlando Bloom, and of course I'm an Elijah Wood freak, so I think he's the best looking one of the bunch. ;-) You WILL find guys to admire in this movie!
Victoria
|
Jan 01 '02
2:51 pm PST
|
|
hmm.. (Reply to this comment)
by jankp
Quite captivating review, but I need a good-looking guy in a movie to keep me entertained for 3 hours. Not elves and gnomes!
Jan
|
Jan 01 '02
2:05 pm PST
|
|
Victoria, I am . . . (Reply to this comment)
by gungian
. . . looking forward to your next posting - it will be #100.
Wishing you and yours a most wonderful 2002.
Write On!
|
Dec 31 '01
4:59 am PST
|
|
My favorite movie.. (Reply to this comment)
by fyvel
I see a LOT of movies, I like some, I hate some, but rarely do I LOVE a movie. I loved this one - I've seen it three times so far and my boyfriend keeps asking me when we are going to go see it again, which will be any day now!
I really enjoyed your review!
~Mandy
|
Dec 30 '01
12:10 pm PST
|
|
Wow... (Reply to this comment)
by arianej
Great review! I am determined to see this movie, even though we rarely make it to the movie theaters these days. I do want reread the book first, as it's been several years, but reviews like yours are certainly big incentives for me to hurry. :)
arianej
|
Dec 30 '01
9:18 am PST
|
|
Could Be Most Helpful...One Day I Will Read All These Reviews... (Reply to this comment)
by kcfoxy
...but I would be highly remiss not to at least stop by and leave a personal note to let you know how very entertaining and helpful your review was! At the current rate of reimbursement...a comment will have to suffice as my coin, and please know this was the best, of many interesting epinions I have read in many a day.
Blessings of the New Year for sharing such quality, intelligent and insightful writing with your Epinions Community!
Casey
|
Dec 30 '01
6:11 am PST
|
|
Great review (Reply to this comment)
by opinionated3
Excellent review, I will have to wait til it comes out on DVD. I remember reading The Tolkien books way back when I was a teen and I can only hope they captured the imagination of Tolkien when he created the story. I have heard a mixed bag of critics who loved it/ hated it. I prefer to hear it from fellow normal people here on Epinions. As far as the Arwen character goes from what I hear they created her character for the Movie version. I will have to re-read the book to see for myself. Great job on your review keep up the great work.
Jon
|
Dec 30 '01
5:34 am PST
|
|
You Know A Movie Is A Success... (Reply to this comment)
by elvisdo,  in Movies
... when it lingers with you well after you have seen it. Though the naysayers scoff at the butchering of certain parts, I was still enchanted with the entire tale. The spirit of the books is evident and that's what has captivated those who have really enjoyed it. Loved your review.
The Grim One
|
Dec 29 '01
10:43 am PST
|
|
This one is bound for my movie collection... (Reply to this comment)
by girlboxer5
You know it's a great movie, when the seven year old behind you protests at the end, "Mommie, that was way too short!" I found myself with the same complaint-- I could easily have sat in the chair for another three hours...
Great review!
Rock on,
Elizabeth
|
Dec 29 '01
9:16 am PST
|
|
|
© 1999-2009 Shopping.com, Inc.