Ripley's Game

4 ratings (4 Epinions reviews)
Epinions Product Rating: Very Good
5 stars
4 stars
3
3 stars
1
2 stars
1 star
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

Scenic but hard-to-believe tale of manipulation and murder(s)

Jan 5, 2004 (Updated Jan 17, 2004)
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review
  • User Rating: Very Good

  • Action Factor:
  • Suspense:

Pros:scenery, soundtrack, John Malkovich

Cons:miscast Dougray Scott, Patricia Highsmith's original premise

The Bottom Line: Not boring, but hard to believe


Plot Details: This opinion reveals major details about the movie's plot.

Liliana Cavani's (2002) adaptation of Ripley's Game isn't dull. Its plausibility problem stems from original author Patricia Highsmith's conception of entrapping an ordinary, decent, fatally ill man to act as a hit man to provide for his wife and young son after his death. Wim Wenders's version (The American Friend) managed to get over this obstacle, but the fetching but somnambulistic Dougray Scott does not convince me. I can understand that there is an advantage in having a killer with no obvious motive, but it's hard to believe a long-term survivor gangster such as Reeves (Ray Winstone, playing another Cockney gangster) would assent to hiring a wholly inexperienced and obviously inept amateur for a job in which failure would be fatal for the gangster.

As an aging, amoral, and very self-satisfied grandee Tom Ripley (moved from France to northern Italy and played by John Malkovich) is notably restrained. There's something of a man waning to toy with others' lives and see what happens (as in "Dangerous Liaisons") and of a resourceful, cold-blooded killer (as in "In the Line of Fire"). He has a beautiful young wife or whatever (Evelina Meghnagi) and a large, restored Palladian villa to protect, but his wealth rests on past association with unsavory operators like Reeves . The sordid past invades the present when Reeves shows up asking Tom to kill a Russian gang lord in Berlin.

I think that making Jonathan, the chosen assassin, another Anglophone expatriate (English or Scottich, in contrast to the American Tom Ripley) was a major mistake. Joanathan should be more completely integrated into the local society than Ripley to make his being wrenched out to commit murders in Germany (Berlin here, rather than Hamburg as in Highsmith's novel and Wender's movie) more dramatic. Also, his shop and home are too spacious and well-appointed for a character who is supposed to be barely getting by. (Homoeroticism has also been banished, though that was stronger in Highsmith's first Ripley novel than in the sequel(s).)

There is a lot of plot, some very graphic violence, quite a lot of black humor, beautiful travelogue-like photography of the Italian countryside, Berlin locales, and, in the finale, of a Palladian theater by expert cinematographer Alfio Contini (who shot) "The Night Porter" for Cavani back in 1974).
.
Updating to an era of cellphones and Russian gangs warring with Ukranian ones worked fine. And Ennio Morricone provides an interesting score. It is sometimes obtrusive, but not distracting.

The movie is not boring, but is also not very involving—primarily, I think, because it's hard to care what happens to Dougray Scott's Jonathan and hard to accept the premise that a tough gangster would go along with Tom Ripley's whim to entrap and degrade Jonathan.




Recommend this product? Yes


Suitability For Children: Not suitable for Children of any age


Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!


Related Deals You Might Like...

Ripley's Game

Ripley's Game

Scorned at an elegant gala, debonair art connoisseur, millionaire, and sociopath Tom Ripley comes up with an ingenious and subtle way to exact his rev...
Sears Marketplace
Ripley's Game eBook

Ripley's Game eBook

Buy Ripley's Game by Patricia Highsmith and Read this Book on Kobo's Free Apps. Discover Kobo's Vast Collection of Ebooks Today - Over 3 Million Titl...
Kobo eBooks

$9.39

FREE Shipping
Ripley's Believe It Or Not (1930-32)

Ripley's Believe It Or Not (1930-32)

You may not believe all you see but you will be entertained by Robert L. Ripley's 24 Theatrical Shorts that are part travelogue part human interest pa...
eBay

$28.58

FREE Shipping
Ripley's Game by Patricia Highsmith

Ripley's Game by Patricia Highsmith

Free Delivery Worldwide : Ripley's Game : Paperback : VINTAGE : 9780099283683 : 0099283689 : 01 Dec 2006 : Tom Ripley detests murder - unless it is ab...
BookDepository.com

$10.71

FREE Shipping
Dallas Cowboys Toddler Ripley Fleece Set - Navy Blue/Gray

Dallas Cowboys Toddler Ripley Fleece Set - Navy Blue/Gray

Help your little all-star cheer on his favorite team in this Ripley fleece set! He’ll be the most adorable Dallas Cowboys fan around when he dons th...
NFL Shop

$34.95

+$4.99 shipping
Talented Mr. Ripley  DVD

Talented Mr. Ripley DVD

Based on Patricia Highsmith's novel of the same name Anthony Minghella's moody follow-up to his Oscar-winning THE ENGLISH PATIENT concerns Tom Ripley ...
Family Video

$9.99

+$2.99 shipping
The Talented Mr Ripley / Ripley under Ground / Ripley's Game by Patricia Highsmith

The Talented Mr Ripley / Ripley under Ground / Ripley's Game by Patricia Highsmith

Free Delivery Worldwide : The Talented Mr Ripley / Ripley under Ground / Ripley's Game : Hardback : Random House USA Inc : 9780375407925 : 0375407928 ...
BookDepository.com

$23.12

FREE Shipping
TALENTED MR. RIPLEY

TALENTED MR. RIPLEY

When Tom Ripley is sent to Italy to bring home a rich and spoiled millionaire playboy, he instead befriends him, then kills him and assumes his life.
Sears Marketplace
Dallas Cowboys Toddler Ripley Fleece Set - Navy Blue/Gray

Dallas Cowboys Toddler Ripley Fleece Set - Navy Blue/Gray

Help your little all-star cheer on his favorite team in this Ripley fleece set! He’ll be the most adorable Dallas Cowboys fan around when he dons th...
NFL Shop

$34.95

+$4.99 shipping
MOD-RIPLEYS BELIEVE IT OR NOT (2 DVD/1930-32/NON-RETURNABLE)

MOD-RIPLEYS BELIEVE IT OR NOT (2 DVD/1930-32/NON-RETURNABLE)

MOD-RIPLEYS BELIEVE IT OR NOT (2 DVD/1930-32/NON-RETURNABLE)DOCUMENTARY NOTE: THIS ITEM IS NOT RETURNABLE UNLESS DEFECTIVE.
Sears Marketplace