VillaWare 5100 Ice Cream Maker Reviews

VillaWare 5100 Ice Cream Maker

5 ratings (5 Epinions reviews)
Epinions Product Rating: OK
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

Is this a lot of work or am I just lazy?

Mar 7, 2005 (Updated Mar 7, 2005)
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review
  • User Rating: Excellent

  • Ease of Use:
  • Durability:
  • Ease of Cleaning:
  • Style:

Pros:makes ice cream, looks attractive

Cons:length of time to make, only makes 1 quart.

The Bottom Line: Makes ice cream without the additives and preservatives.

I am brushing up on my summer cooking skills by making ice cream! Ice Cream seems to be a favorite around here especially when the spring and summer arrive. I thought that it might be beneficial to make our own ice cream. Little did I know how much work was involved in making ice cream!

I chose the VillaWare Ice Cream Maker because…well it was the only one to choose from at Target. I have been wanting an ice cream maker for awhile but never had the gumption to crank a lever. When I saw this automatic one I figured I was on easy street and put it into my cart.

I opened the box up at the store so I could see the ingredients in the instruction booklet because I wanted to start making ice cream as soon as I got home. I picked up heavy whipping cream which is around $5.00 for 1 quart and usually make 3 batches of ice cream. Half-and-Half is another common ingredient for the recipes. I also purchased chocolate squares, frozen strawberries, and plain yogurt so I could make several different kinds.

I got home and was ready to start but that idea was quickly foiled by the 6 hour minimum time frame that the freezer bowl needs. To prepare the freezer bowl, wash and dry it and place it in a bag (I use a grocery bag) and put it in the freezer until it is frozen solid which takes 6-22 hours depending on each freezer.

I never bothered to read more of the directions so when it came time to make the ice cream I was in shock to find out that I had to cook the mixture on the stove and then let it cool down before continuing. For some reason I thought I just poured things in and waited. It took some time to add the ingredients, bring them to a certain temperature, cook for a few minutes and then allow to cool and clean up the mess.

Once the ingredients were cool I placed them into the freezer bowl, inserted the paddle, placed the cover over it, and turned the appliance on to low speed. There is an opening at the top of the cover that they claim is for adding more ingredients like nuts to the ice cream near the end but I think the real reason it’s there is for taste testing. My first batch of ice cream was old fashioned chocolate ice cream and we were off to a rough start. After all the work and waiting the motor of the ice cream maker did not start. I would definitely recommend plugging the appliance in a making sure it runs before beginning. We ended up getting it going and have not had any problems with it since then.

I could hear the motor running but it was not loud or annoying. The ice cream churns for 25 minutes or until it is turned off; it does not have an automatic shut-off. It doesn’t really matter that it doesn’t have automatic shut off because ice cream can’t sit out anyway. After the ice cream was finished it was still too runny to eat so I poured it into a freezer safe bowl and put it into the freezer to harden. We came back a couple hours later to find perfect ice cream.

I was a little surprised that our first batch turned out so well but there’s not much to it. I have never made ice cream before so I was pleased to see a large selection of recipes included in the instruction booklet such as:

Ice creams: Chocolate, Strawberry, Peanut butter, Peach, Vanilla, Sugar-free Black Walnut, Holiday eggnog

Frozen yogurts: Sugar-free Raspberry Frozen Yogurt, Chocolate, vanilla, Blackberry, Strawberry

Sherbet: Raspberry, Pineapple

Gelato: Chocolate, Gelato de Ricotta, Hazelnut

Sorbet: Bittersweet, chocolate mocha, Apple Juice, Kiwi

Any other 1 quart recipe that you have can be used.

The ice cream maker requires hand washing which I am strongly against but since it is ice cream it washes away easily without scrubbing. Warm water and dish soap is all that can be used with the appliance. The motor should not be put in water.

The ice cream maker is attractive. The motor base is stainless steel and is attractive enough to be on the countertop if necessary. There is an area in the back for cord storage. There is a 1 year warranty against workmanship and defects and shipping is paid by the buyer.

One of the reasons I wanted an ice cream maker was because of food allergies. When you make your own ice cream you can use the ingredients that work best for you. Recipes that call for heavy cream can also be modified with half-and-half or milk.

Making the ingredients for the ice cream is really simple and I haven’t had any trouble with the recipes coming out right. We go through a lot of ice cream so 1 batch really only lasts 1-2 days for us so we are constantly making more ice cream.

It is very difficult to find a level area in my freezer for the freezer bowl to sit. I had to designate a shelf just for ice cream.

I have tried lots of variations but I really only prefer the full calorie ice cream. We usually eat Bluebell or Ben & Jerry’s ice cream. We still think that store bought is better than homemade.

I seemingly don’t play with my kitchen toys any more than my kids play with their toys. This is another toy that I had to have but probably don’t need. The ice cream maker does make some tasty ice cream but it takes a lot of planning and effort to get one little quart of ice cream. I thought making ice cream at home would be cheaper since it only takes a few ingredients however I have found that I could buy a lot of ice cream for the amount that I spend making my own starting with the $50 that I paid for the machine. Overall the ice cream maker does what it says it will do. It’s not the machine’s fault that I’m too lazy to make my own ice cream.

VillaWare Manufacturing Co.
18901 Euclid Ave No. 1
Cleveland, OH 44117
Phone: 866-484-5529

Other fun summer gadgets:
Oster Blender
Disney Smoothie Maker
Rival Snow Cone Maker

Recommend this product? Yes

Amount Paid (US$): 50.00

Read all comments (2)

Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!

Related Deals You Might Like...

Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker

Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker

Find ice cream and yogurt makers at! Simply place the aluminum canister filled with ingredients in the center of the bucket, layer the plas...


+$8.77 shipping
Disney Ice Cream Maker

Disney Ice Cream Maker



FREE Shipping
Cuisinart Ice-100 Ice Cream Maker

Cuisinart Ice-100 Ice Cream Maker

Cuisinart Ice-100 Ice Cream Maker


FREE Shipping
SPT 1.5-qt. Ice Cream Maker

SPT 1.5-qt. Ice Cream Maker

SPT 1.5-qt. Ice Cream Maker. Frozen treats in as little as 20 minutes! Sweet relief from the summer heat! Make a wide range of tasty frozen treats in ...
Sportsman's Guide


+$18.99 shipping
Cuisinart Ice Cream Makers Ice Cream And Gelato Maker Stainless Look ICE-100

Cuisinart Ice Cream Makers Ice Cream And Gelato Maker Stainless Look ICE-100

Shop for Appliances at The Home Depot. Make lusciously rich gelato and ice cream batch after batch right at home. The Cuisinart Ice Cream and Gelato M...
Home Depot


FREE Shipping
Cuisinart Compressor Ice Cream and Gelato Maker

Cuisinart Compressor Ice Cream and Gelato Maker

Make lusciously rich gelato and ice cream - batch after batch - right at home! The Cuisinart Ice Cream and Gelato Maker has a commercial quality compr...


FREE Shipping
Whynter Ice Cream Maker ICM-15LS

Whynter Ice Cream Maker ICM-15LS

Whynter ICM-15LS With the Whynther ICM-15LS stainless steel frozen dessert ice cream maker, you can make a spread of delectable desserts in about 30-...


FREE Shipping
Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker (Brushed Stainless)

Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker (Brushed Stainless)

The fully automatic Cuisinart Pure Indulgence ice cream maker makes 2 quarts of your favorite frozen desserts or drinks in as little as 25 minutes. It...
Chefs Resource


FREE Shipping
Cuisinart Ice-45 Ice Cream Maker, Soft Serve Mix-it-In

Cuisinart Ice-45 Ice Cream Maker, Soft Serve Mix-it-In

Customize your cone with this ingenious soft serve ice cream maker that automatically adds up to three of your favorite mix-ins. Make a heaping 1-1/2 ...


FREE Shipping
Whynter Ice Cream Maker - Stainless Steel Multicolor - ICM-15LS

Whynter Ice Cream Maker - Stainless Steel Multicolor - ICM-15LS

Shop for Ice Cream Makers from! Enjoy delicious ice cream whenever the mood hits you with the Whynter Ice Cream Maker - Stainless Steel....


FREE Shipping