Melting Pot

71 ratings (70 Epinions reviews)
Epinions Product Rating: Excellent
5 stars
37
4 stars
18
3 stars
4
2 stars
6
1 star
5
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

Do Fun with Fondue at the Melting Pot

Nov 22, 2006
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review

Pros:good cheese fondue with unlimited dippers, pretty good service, chocolate fondue tasty

Cons:slow, small chocolate portion, some entree options only for couples, very difficult to get seating

The Bottom Line: I probably wouldn't get a dessert fondue again but I would get the cheese fondue again in a heartbeat.


I like fondue but I rarely get the chance to indulge. The good, cheap fondue restaurant in Boston closed years ago. A newer fondue restaurant opened a couple of years ago but it's not conveniently located and it's outrageously expensive making it less than attractive.

I'd been craving fondue for a while but was resigned to foregoing the pleasure until I stumbled on a Melting Pot during my recent trip to Pittsburgh. I immediately decided to have dinner there that night.

Unfortunately the Melting Pot is very popular and even on a Thursday night around 7:30 there was a 2-2.5 hour wait for a table. Even though I was starving I might have waited if I could get transportation back to my hotel that late, but faced with both a growling stomach and the thought of cabfare I left. I vowed to return, though, and two nights later I did just that.

Not surprisingly, the restaurant was even busier on a Saturday night. I'd intended to call ahead but accidentally left the card with the phone number in my hotel room that morning. Thus, I was faced with choice of waiting 3-3.5 hours and taking a cab back to my hotel or eating at the bar which, surprisingly, accommodated fondue pots. After a great deal of deliberation, I decided to eat at the bar.

I rarely do this because the high stools and chairs used for bar seating are uncomfortable and because there's no space for bags and packages. This Melting Pot was no exception; my knees hurt after two hours of sitting on their chairs and I had to place my single small plastic bag on the floor and hope for the best (surprisingly it survived). One other thing to watch for is cigarette smoke. While most states no longer allow smoking in restaurants, some states exempt the bar area. That means that in addition to any bar patrons who choose to smoke you'll be dealing with other diners who stop by between courses to sneak a puff.

Unfortunately one of the advantages of sitting at the bar - readily available drink refills - was rendered moot by the need to get iced tea from the kitchen. Despite this the two bartenders did a reasonable job keeping up with water and iced tea refills.

The service in general was pretty good although at times it was difficult to get the attention of a bartender despite there being two of them and only around a dozen folks seated at the bar. One of the two bartenders was a bit dour but he got whatever was needed in a timely fashion so I can't really say he had an attitude problem. Still, there was a marked difference between his demeanor and that of his compatriot.

Of course none of that matters much if the food isn't good. Fortunately it was. The Melting Pot offers three types of fondue: cheese, meat, and chocolate. The cheese fondue comes in five varieties: a mix of swiss cheeses, a mix of cheddar and swiss, a mix of Wisconsin cheeses, a fiesta mix with jalapenos and salsa, and a chef's special. Each includes garlic or other seasonings and most have a little bit of either beer or wine for a richer flavor.

Each of the cheese fondues comes with an unlimited supply of two types of breads, tart green apple slices, carrots, celery, and cauliflower for $14. The portion of cheese is very generous and is more than sufficient for a meal for one or an appetizer for several. I ordered the cheddar and swiss mix which was perhaps slightly too sharp but still very good.

The meat fondues are available as traditional oil fondues, with a broth base, or with a wine base (for an extra $5 fee). They come with one or more meats with choices including chicken, beef, pork, shrimp, salmon, duck, and lobster. Some are available solo and others only as part of combination plates. Many entree fondues are available for the solo diner but some require a party of two. All of these choices come with vegetables as well including potatoes, squash, mushrooms, and broccoli. Prices vary greatly depending on the selections made but generally run $20-40 per person. I can't speak to portion size or taste since I didn't order anything from this part of the menu.

The dessert fondues are all about chocolate. Available in two sizes for $14 or $28, the Melting Pot offers more than a dozen varieties of dessert fondue. You can go plain (straight milk, dark, or white chocolate) or get more creative with the addition of ingredients like peanut butter, marshmallow, crushed oreos, caramel, and more. They all come with a small plate of bite sized bits of pound cake, brownie, marshmallow, strawberry, banana, and pineapple for dipping and a tiny slice of cheesecake.

I ordered a small dark chocolate and while tasty it wasn't very large. The pot was less than 20 percent full, but even so I ran out of dippers before chocolate. I wished I'd saved some of my apples; I thought they'd be divine in the chocolate. If you want to share and want more than a bite or two you'll have to order a large.

I enjoyed my meal at the Melting Pot but I probably won't get a dessert fondue if I ever have the chance to go again. While tasty, the portion is just too small to justify the cost. I would get the cheese fondue again in a heartbeat, though, and definitely recommend it to anyone who likes fondue. Just pick a night when you aren't in any kind of rush - you're going to be there for a few hours - and make a reservation then enjoy.


Recommend this product? Yes

Read all comments (1)

Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!


Related Deals You Might Like...

Farberware Melting Pot 5/8-qt. Butter Warmer

Farberware Melting Pot 5/8-qt. Butter Warmer

This Farberware melting pot proves that good things come in small packages. Limit 5 per household. Product Features: Stainless steel construction ensu...
Kohl's

$9.99

+$5.95 shipping
Farberware Classic Series Melting Pot Butter Warmer

Farberware Classic Series Melting Pot Butter Warmer

Find cookware, open stock and sets at Target.com! This diminutive piece is designed to melt butter, warm milk, or heat sauces. It features a handy pou...
Target

$9.99

+$5.43 shipping
Farberware Classic Series Melting Pot .625-quart Butter Warmer, Stainless Steel

Farberware Classic Series Melting Pot .625-quart Butter Warmer, Stainless Steel

Welcome To Shopfreely Home Contact Us Our Feedback About Us Add to Favorites Lighting TV Stands Bar Stools Home Decor Baby Kids' Furniture All Lightin...
eBay

$9.99

+$5.95 shipping
Koolatron Cm10g-ca Chocolate Melting Pot

Koolatron Cm10g-ca Chocolate Melting Pot

Koolatron CM10G-CA Koolatron CM10G-CA Chocolate Melting Pot Description Starting with our flagship product line of 12V portable thermoelectric cooler ...
eBay

$36.02

FREE Shipping
Lodge  Cast Iron Melting Pot

Lodge Cast Iron Melting Pot

Grandma was on to something with the timeless cast iron skillet, preferred by many chefs. Ready-to-use pre-seasoned pot gives that homespun cast iron ...
Crate & Barrel

$19.95

FREE Shipping
Lodge Cast Iron Seasoned Melting Pot Kit w/ Brush & Recipe Book

Lodge Cast Iron Seasoned Melting Pot Kit w/ Brush & Recipe Book

The Specialty Cookware by Lodge: Standard Features and Benefits Kit includes: 14-oz. cast iron melting pot for melting butter and warming barbeque sa...
KaTom Restaurant Supply
Hot Pot II Lead Melting Pot Lure Building & Mold   20850

Hot Pot II Lead Melting Pot Lure Building & Mold 20850

Heating element is mounted externally for longer life. Includes 3inchx1-3/4inch, 4-lb. lead capacity cast-iron pot, heat-resistant plastic handle, met...
Bass Pro Shops

$49.99

+$7.95 shipping
14oz Melting Pot Pre Seasoned Cast Iron Non Stick Kitchen Stove Oven Accessories

14oz Melting Pot Pre Seasoned Cast Iron Non Stick Kitchen Stove Oven Accessories

Perfect for warming butter, melting cheese, scalding milk or heating syrup. Versatile for stovetop or BBQ grill. Sure to become your favorite pot for ...
eBay

$21.41

FREE Shipping
Sur La Table Tri-Ply Stainless Steel Butter-Melting Pot

Sur La Table Tri-Ply Stainless Steel Butter-Melting Pot

This petite multi-tasker does much more than melt butter. Its great for warming sauces or syrup, reheating tea or soup, and much more. Plus, the small...
Sur La Table

$49.95

+$10.50 shipping
Round Melting Pot Cast Iron Pre Seasoned 4.5 X 2.5 Deep Lodge Logic Lmp3 F4743

Round Melting Pot Cast Iron Pre Seasoned 4.5 X 2.5 Deep Lodge Logic Lmp3 F4743

F OR SALE IS THIS NEW LODGE LOGIC 4 1/2diameter x 2 1/2 deep CAST IRON MELTING POT MPN LMP3 F4743 UPC# 075536339900 . LIKE ALL LODGE CAST IRON, THIS L...
eBay

$23.41

+$6.23 shipping