Papa John's Pizza

280 ratings (267 Epinions reviews)
Epinions Product Rating: Very Good
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

Hes NOT my Papa.

Mar 23, 2006 (Updated Mar 23, 2006)
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review

Pros:They deliver.

Cons:If they are late, they're lost.

The Bottom Line: My tastebuds say no.

I received a mailer from Papa John’s today and was prompted to write a review even though there are many reviews of this establishment. I have ordered from Papa John’s for many years due to an anonymous decision. I was always against it. The reason I receive them is because several times we have ordered online for pick-up or delivery and therefore my home must be on their mailing list. The flier came with 2 coupons which are good for 6 weeks. It was very easy to order after you register. You can take your time and view the menu which gives you time to decide and order in advance then pick it up if you are going to be out or they will deliver. Also, if you don’t have any coupons, you can check out their specials which changes frequently. The website is fairly easy to navigate. They did have anchovies as a topping, but whenever I called to place an order they would tell me they do not have anchovies at that location and I did tell them why don’t they remove it from their website. I have not ordered from them for a long time. I just decided to check their website to see if they still offer it, and noticed it has been removed.

What, no anchovies?
Most Italians like anchovies on their pizza occasionally. Is John Schnatter Italian? Doesn’t seem like to me. But you don’t have to be Italian to make pizza. On the Menu and Nutrition page of the website, it lists anchovies but states “Toppings may vary per restaurant”. I’m still confused, sometimes they list it then it’s only by location. I can’t figure that one out. The Nutritional page lists the values for dieters for each different size slice of pie. Very helpful for those with diabetes, heart condition and any watching their calorie intake.

Papa John makes 8 Signature Pizzas and Create Your Own (Lg Only). They offer 16 toppings. Dipping sauces are $.40. Their Extras include Sweetreat cinna swirl, breadsticks, cheesesticks, garlic breadsticks, chickenstrips and Papa’s wings. I’ve only tried the cinnaswirl when they first came out they gave free samples with the pizza order.

I must say that Papa John’s and Pizza Hut really leave me with a bad aftertaste. I don’t know what it is about these 2 chains, but I try not eat either pizzas too often. I do prefer Pizza Hut over Papa John’s though. Pizza Hut does have anchovies. Papa’s pies are a bit sweeter but Pizza Hut’s dough is better tasting to me. Pizza Hut’s pies are a few dollars more for the largest pie. I also have ordered from Domino’s until one day I picked up a pie and noticed a delivery guy go and help make pizzas since they were behind in orders and start making pies without washing his hands. Needless to say, that was my last order from Domino’s.

My preference is if I want Italian pizza I have to have it from a local Italian pizzeria. I like that extra grease. Not because I’m Italian, but I think it just tastes better. My family members all have their own favorite place which we all cannot agree on. So deciding on a pizzeria is difficult when we want pizza. Sometimes we take turns in choosing. They only sell Coke, Diet Coke & Sprite in the 2 liter bottles.

He’s lost!
Their delivery to my home has not been reliable. They have gone to a different home and then when the time I was given had expired, I would call and they told me he was on his way with an apology that he went to a wrong address, even though I would always make them repeat my address. Their drivers are not really swift with directions. Perhaps the reason being their drivers don’t last long since many times I saw different people. This would cause the pizzas to arrive cooled, not to my liking.

I love pizza for breakfast, lunch or dinner. But as for
Papa John’s, I would give it 1 1/2 stars. They do try to make the best but it’s not “Better” for my taste. (to order online)

Recommend this product? No

Read all comments (3)

Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!

Related Deals You Might Like...

Good Cook Pizza Stone

Good Cook Pizza Stone

Find bakeware and ovenware at! The good cook pizza stone lets you make delicious, fresh pizza, bread and dinner rolls at home. It uniformly...


+$8.46 shipping
Norpro Cake & Pizza Lifter

Norpro Cake & Pizza Lifter

Norpro Cake & Pizza Lifter Norpro Cake & Pizza Lifter Pizza Lifter & Cake Lifter Move hot pizza to serving tray. The smart way to lift cakes onto serv...


+$5.95 shipping
Farberware Soft Touch 13 Pizza Crisper

Farberware Soft Touch 13 Pizza Crisper

A perfect pizza has bubbling melted cheese on top and a crispy-chewy crust on the bottom. This perforated pizza crisper is designed to deliver maximum...


+$8.00 shipping
Farberware Pizza & Bread Baking 13 in. Pizza Crisper in Light Brown 52149

Farberware Pizza & Bread Baking 13 in. Pizza Crisper in Light Brown 52149

In the interest of a crisp pizza, the perforated bottom of this pan is designed to deliver as much heat as possible to the bottom crust. In addition t...
Home Depot


+$5.99 shipping
Pizzacraft Aluminum Pizza Peel - PC0202

Pizzacraft Aluminum Pizza Peel - PC0202

Shop for Gadgets and Tools from! The Pizzacraft Aluminum Pizza Peel slides easily under raw dough with just a light dusting of cornmeal....


+$5.99 shipping
Breville 12Diam Pizza Pan

Breville 12Diam Pizza Pan

Don't go out for pizza. Make it at home on this 12Diam nonstick pan. Designed for use with the Breville Compact Smart Oven, the pizza pan may also be ...


+$3.00 shipping
Haeger Round Pizza Stone

Haeger Round Pizza Stone

Make the perfect pizza with our Haeger Round Pizza Stone crafted of natural stoneware. Your family will be pleased with the delicious tasting, crisper...
Sturbridge Yankee Workshop


+$9.99 shipping
Lodge Logic Professional Pizza Pan - Lodge Pro-Logic

Lodge Logic Professional Pizza Pan - Lodge Pro-Logic

Molds & Specialty Bakeware - The Lodge pizza pan produces a golden crust every time. It is also great for roasted vegetables, pork chops, chicken and ...
CHEFS Catalog


FREE Shipping
OXO Nonstick Pizza Wheel

OXO Nonstick Pizza Wheel

Plastic wheel wont damage nonstick pizza pans, and its slick surface helps shed melted cheese and other toppings. Soft-grip handle with thumb guard pr...
Sur La Table


+$5.50 shipping
Emile Henry 617514 Pizza Baking Stone

Emile Henry 617514 Pizza Baking Stone

The Pizza Baking Stone by Emile Henry: The pizza stone is made of all natural materials and is manufactured using Emile Henry's proprietary Flame tech...
KaTom Restaurant Supply


FREE Shipping