Saving Private Ryan

320 ratings (308 Epinions reviews)
Epinions Product Rating: Excellent
5 stars
218
4 stars
52
3 stars
21
2 stars
11
1 star
5
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

Saving Private Ryan: Schindler's List it ain't...

Mar 14, 2000 (Updated Jul 16, 2001)
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review

Pros:Epic Battle Scenes

Cons:Lame story

The Bottom Line: It has harrowing battle scenes and a hoaky storyline. Watch an Audie Murphy WWII movie instead.


Director Steven Spielberg's "Saving Private Ryan" was an intensely gripping movie for the first 30 minutes - and the last 30 minutes -- specifically the two big battle scenes: D-Day and the Battle at Newville. The middle hour and a half consisted of competent acting by Hanks and one or two others, especially the sniper character and the coward. But the film was hindered by a lagging story that really didn't tug at my heart strings like "Schindler's List" did. I think that was what Spielberg intended; follow the formula that made "Schindler's List" a success, only change it enough to make it different. You can tell that from the sandwich technique beginning and ending, just like "Schindler's List", had, only different.

I really can't blame Spielberg for trying to capitalize on such a brilliant film as "Schindler", but it is very hard for two gigantic successes on the same format, like lightning striking twice in the same spot!

The basic idea behind the movie, finding the last of four sons of an Iowa mother and returning him to her unharmed, is screwy from the first inkling, and repugnant to any red-blooded American male, smacking as it does of apron strings, meddling, and future accusations and shamed-faced denials. But screwy is what the Army does, often enough, and Private Ryan's response to the idea is what I had hoped: "Take your rescue party and shove it. I'm staying with my buddies."

This decision proves costly to all concerned, as Hanks and companions decide to gut it out with Ryan -- they can't return without him! At least seven of the original eight rescuers, including Hanks, are sacrificed on the altar of German steel for the Pentagon's folly.

Do not get me wrong, it is a good movie. I just do not see it as the greatest of war movies. For that, I would recommend "To Hell and Back", "Hell is for Heroes", "The Great Escape", "Siege of Firebase Gloria", "Zulu", "They Died With Their Boots On", "Son of the Morning Star", "55 Days at Peking, or "Khartoum."


Recommend this product? Yes

Read all comments (5)

Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!


Related Deals You Might Like...

Saving Private Ryan

Saving Private Ryan

Saving Private Ryan is the realistic and emotional story of a World War II Army captain who lands on Omaha Beach on D-Day and is given the task of fin...
eBay

$8.77

+$1.90 shipping
Saving Private Ryan (dvd, 1999, Special Limited Edition) Brand

Saving Private Ryan (dvd, 1999, Special Limited Edition) Brand

Saving Private Ryan is the realistic and emotional story of a World War II Army captain who lands on Omaha Beach on D-Day and is given the task of fin...
eBay

$12.82

FREE Shipping
Saving Private Ryan: Tie In

Saving Private Ryan: Tie In

Saving Private Ryan: Tie In
Sears Marketplace
Saving Private Ryan - Dvd

Saving Private Ryan - Dvd

Saving Private Ryan is the realistic and emotional story of a World War II Army captain who lands on Omaha Beach on D-Day and is given the task of fin...
eBay

$13.49

+$2.94 shipping
Saving Private Ryan (Widescreen)

Saving Private Ryan (Widescreen)

DVD, R, 170 minutes, DREAMWORKS
Walmart.com

$9.66

+$4.97 shipping
Saving Private Ryan & MP3 Pack: Level 6 by Max Allan Collins

Saving Private Ryan & MP3 Pack: Level 6 by Max Allan Collins

Free Delivery Worldwide : Saving Private Ryan & MP3 Pack: Level 6 : Mixed media product : Pearson Education Limited : 9781408274415 : 1408274418 : 09 ...
BookDepository.com

$13.24

FREE Shipping
Saving Private Ryan Special Limited Edition DVD

Saving Private Ryan Special Limited Edition DVD

Director Steven Spielberg's World War II tour de force chronicles the journey of a GI squad on a dangerous mission behind enemy lines. Led by Captain ...
Family Video

$10.99

+$2.99 shipping
SAVING PRIVATE RYAN (DVD) (WS)

SAVING PRIVATE RYAN (DVD) (WS)

SAVING PRIVATE RYAN (DVD) (WS)DRAMA A SMALL BAND OF U.S. SOLDIERS ARE SENT ON A MISSION DURING THE TUMULTUOUS BATTLE AT NORMANDY TO FIND THE LONE SURV...
Sears Marketplace
Saving Private Ryan (vhs, 2005)

Saving Private Ryan (vhs, 2005)

Director Steven Spielberg's World War II tour de force chronicles the journey of a GI squad on a dangerous mission behind enemy lines. Led by Captain ...
eBay

$5.99

FREE Shipping
11 x 17 Saving Private Ryan Movie Poster - 1998

11 x 17 Saving Private Ryan Movie Poster - 1998

World War II. Eight soldiers. One mission. Led by their captain, a group has to go behind enemy lines to rescue a downed paratrooper in a harrowing dr...
QVC

$16.54

+$5.97 shipping