Click to see larger image
Seagate STAA1500601 1.5 TB,External (STAA1500601(1500GB)) Portable
(1 Epinions review)
Like communism- good idea that just does not work well.
Oct 30, 2011 (Updated Nov 1, 2011)
Review by Michael Kamentsev
Rated a Very Helpful Review
Pros:1.5TB, USB-powered,1/3 the size/weight of 110-volt powered, external drive? WOW!
Cons:Wastes your time- not reliable for USB 2.0 machines (at least).
The Bottom Line: I wasted a couple of hours on copying .8TB of data on this drive, being successful on placing .6TB on it only, w/ USB2.0. It's flaky, spare your time.
HOW THIS DRIVE IS EXPECTED TO WORK
Recommend this product?
I retired from assembling computers myself- I like a reliable device with reliable software recovery system. I'm tired of wasting time on hardware. That's why I like Apple Computer products, if it's reliable from start- you are in luck.
This drive supports the new USB3.0, advertised to be 10x faster than the USB2.0 (which this drive also supports). I used it with a desktop and a laptop with USB2.0 to copy video files onto this drive.
I expected from this drive: simplicity and reliability, same as I get from my Iomega eGo 1TB 110volt powered external hard drive. Instead I got (after loading .5 TB of movies on it) problems copying files onto it:
a) Message states that file (I try to copy to this 1.5TB drive) does not exist on the 1.5TB drive. Why should it exist when it is yet to be copied at the time the message is displayed?
b) Message states that basically the drive letter (created for this drive) does not exist. Connection is lost type of notification?
c) My 3 year old Dell XPS laptop (Core 2Duo top of the line upgraded to Windows 7) with its USB 2.0 would power this drive up, only half of the time. When powered up the drive letter for it will not appear in Windows Explorer.
d) My old HP PC crawling Windows XP on Pentium4, runs with it 0K until I gett messages a) & b) seen above.
c) My work laptop is top of the line Pentium i7 machine- I have no clue if it has USB3.0, possibly (I got it in April 2011), but I got messages a) and b) seen above, on it too.
ISSUES LOADING DATA ON IT WITH USB 2.0
I have limited experience running USB-powered external hard drive, namely I used a friend's Western Digital portable USB2.0 powered 0.5TB model without a problem, quote.
This drive worked well when connected to my Western Digital media player- that's about all the praise I have for it. Did it break down on me? Did its cable go bad in 48 hours of use? Is it something like you can read below I googled on Western Digital USB-powered drives problems, quote:
"If your drive is not visible under Device Manager means the particular hardware is not installed properly. This symptom is more common on the drives that are not getting adequate DC power. Check both WD provided USB cable and the micro USB port on your drive under a magnifying glass for possible pin damage or dirt build-up. If cable or port dirty, you can clean it with a small (¼”) artist brush soaked with alcohol. Dry throughout prior to reconnection. If the cable is the culprit, get a replacement cable from WD. Most of the other cables available on the market won’t work. If your USB port on drive is broken, or USB>SATA interface gone bad, you have no other option but to get the drive replaced."
The look and feel:
This drive is 3 times smaller than regular wall powered external drive. It's sleek with rounded edges, and there's a plastic piece connected to the main rectange of the drive, where you connect a 1ft USB cable (which could have been 2 feet for convenience). The aforementioned plastic piece the length of the narrow side of the drive's body swings up and down- that makes me worry as to why it does that, and what's its purpose? Does the main HD cover get heat up too much, or it hosts a fuse (no mention of this anywhere). But I just worry since I had this drive for 48 hours and it works part time when it comes to loading files on it- I don't want a part of the HD case to be moving few millimeters up and down- it might as well eventually fall off.
USB powered drives actually have a set of known issues:
1) Not recognized on connect (due to DC power issues)
2) Stop being recognized by OS (God knows why)
3) Soiled connectors break up drive-PC communication
4) It used to work, but stopped for God knows which reason.
5) Who knows what else non-sensical (thanks to President Bush Jr. for making that work up) to expect during file upload?
I am not going to investigate if this drive went bad or not- I don't want to get another one. These have 2 year warranty but using warranty is a waste of time for me.
I had an internal Western Digital Barracuda drive crash on me irreparably (the head fell on cylinders, so it was beyond repair) causing the loss of my family pictures, so I don't want to recommend trying WD external drive (as far as I know limited to 1TB max at this time). Maybe this drive would work perfectly for those of us who only have the latest machines equipped with USB3.0. If you have USB2.0 chances are not in your favor that the drive will work well for you- out of 3 computers I tired, it's useless on 1 laptop, and stops working at some point on my other laptop, and PC.
I'll return this $110 drive back to Costco, their generous return policy might give me time to try the next generation of WD drive powered via USB. If it also ends up wasting my time, I'll just get a 3TB wall plug drive instead, knowing it won't let me down. I'll better waste time in a casino, or put a thousand piece puzzle together- it calms nerves down at least, instead of getting this USB-powered drive digirama agitation!
NEED YOUR HELP
Please let me know if you know a reliable hard drive powered by USB which is at least 1.5TB- hopefully under $150.
Share this product review with your friends
Carry your data with you, wherever you go, with the FreeAgent GoFlex STAA500105 hard drive. With the Mac and Windows compatibility of this Seagate por...
Enjoy the feeling of never having to worry about storage space again with the Seagate Backup Plus Black 1 TB. The Seagate Backup Plus Black 1 TB offer...
This Seagate Expansion STBV1000100 external USB 3.0 hard drive provides 1TB of storage space for your desktop, making it easy to back up important fil...
Seagate STBV3000100 Expansion Desktop 3TB External Hard Drive Travel with tons of files using the Seagate STBV3000100 Expansion Desktop 3TB External H...
The Seagate STAY2000102 is a Seagate external hard drive from the minimalist Expansion series. With a capacity of 2 TB, this Seagate external hard dri...
Seagate 2TB Expansion External Desktop USB 3.0 Hard Drive, 4.8Gbps Transfer Rate The Seagate 2TB Expansion External hard drive offers an easy-to-use s...
The Seagate Expansion external hard drive by Seagate offers an easy-to-use solution when you need to instantly add data storage to your computer.
The Seagate STBV3000100 is an external hard drive that is designed to store important data files. This Seagate 3 TB hard drive is simple to operate an...
Seagate Expansion 3TB USB 3.0 Desktop External Hard Drive
The Seagate 3 TB hard drive is a portable hard drive that is small enough to be carried in a backpack, a computer case, or another small bag. The Seag...