The Country Girl (DVD, 2009, Value Line)

1 ratings (1 Epinions review)
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

The Country Girl (1954)

May 6, 2000
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review

Pros:cast, musical numbers

Cons:script, direction

Many years ago, when I was young and before I had seen thousands of different movies, I was transfixed by The Country Girl. I channel surfed onto it on late night television, and thought it was sterling psychological drama.

Perhaps it is due to the cynicism of passing years, or from seeing one too many addiction dramas. Perhaps I was simply naive back then. But The Country Girl now seems like standard psychobabble melodrama. The successful, award-winning film is talky and obvious, with an unlikely ending and an unnecessary secondary romance.

Based on the play by Clifford Odets, the film stars Bing Crosby as faded actor/singer Frank Elgin. A family tragedy has caused him to turn to drink, but he is still supported by his embittered wife Georgie (Grace Kelly). Bernie Dodd (William Holden) is a director of a new musical play, and wants Frank to have the lead role. But Frank's alcoholism interferes, while tension mounts between Bernie and Georgie.

The role was ideal for Crosby, who finally had a chance to show his acting talents in a dramatic role. However, the film perks up considerably when he is singing, especially in a duet with Jacqueline Fontaine.

Grace Kelly was only 25 at the time, but the gorgeous, glamorous star was made frumpy by adding glasses, and by changing her dress and hairstyle. Her miscast was made more obvious by the quarter century age difference between her and Crosby.

Of course, it worked out for her, as she demonstrated that she could play a humorless shrew as capably as she could a soft-spoken fashion model. This unrewarding extension of her acting range seems to have made an undeserved impression, as any woman can play an unhappy, self-sacrificing housewife. The challenge comes in making the role both credible and sympathetic, which wasn't really accomplished.

William Holden actually has the most difficult role. His tough guy, hard-edged character has to turn around cunning drinker Frank, win over seething Georgie, and put off sarcastic, ill- tempered producer Phil Cook (Anthony Ross). He also has to pretend that his play, a tame musical starring Frank as a singing farmer, is worth all the testosterone and adrenaline that he is putting into it. He has to be convincing in all this while delivering a blizzard of lines, many of which are loaded with dubious psychological posturing.

The story has strong similarity to that of a vastly superior film about alcoholism from the same year, A Star is Born (1954). The fading star and drunk from that film was played by James Mason, whose behavior was not subjected to relentless psychoanalysis. Also, while the charm of Crosby's voice has to be noted, he was no match for the intensity or variety of Judy Garland's performances.

1954 was the year of On the Waterfront, which dominated the Academy Awards. Nonetheless, The Country Girl was nominated for seven Oscars. Grace Kelly somehow beat Judy Garland for Best Actress, while George Seaton won for his screenplay.

Seaton's direction was also nominated, as was Crosby for Best Actor, and John F. Warren for his cinematography. The film was nominated for Best Picture, and for Best Art Direction. (55/100)



Recommend this product? No

Read all comments (3)

Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!


Related Deals You Might Like...

Girl Free Country Coat Down Jacket Hood Blue Pink Thumb Hole Youth 10/12 M

Girl Free Country Coat Down Jacket Hood Blue Pink Thumb Hole Youth 10/12 M

bowlby5 Store FREE COUNTRY - Girls DOWN Jacket Description Brand New With Tags Attached BRAND: FREE COUNTRY Girls Fleece Lined Down Jacket Youth Size:...
eBay

$33.95

FREE Shipping
Girl Free Country Coat Down Jacket Hood Blue Pink Thumb Hole Youth 5-6 Xs

Girl Free Country Coat Down Jacket Hood Blue Pink Thumb Hole Youth 5-6 Xs

bowlby5 Store FREE COUNTRY - Girls DOWN Jacket Description Brand New With Tags Attached BRAND: FREE COUNTRY Girls Fleece Lined Down Jacket Youth Size:...
eBay

$33.95

FREE Shipping
Country Girl DVD

Country Girl DVD

Alcoholic has-been actor Frank Elgin Bing Crosby is given one last chance to make a comeback--and save his relationship with his frustrated wife Georg...
Family Video

$5.99

+$1.99 shipping
Girl Free Country Coat Down Jacket Hood Black Pink Thumb Hole Youth 16 - Xl

Girl Free Country Coat Down Jacket Hood Black Pink Thumb Hole Youth 16 - Xl

bowlby5 Store FREE COUNTRY - Girls DOWN Coat Youth Girls Size: X-Large (16) Description Brand New With Tags Attached BRAND: FREE COUNTRY Girls Fleece ...
eBay

$33.95

FREE Shipping
Fruit Of The Loom Girls Crew Sock 10 Pair Value Pack

Fruit Of The Loom Girls Crew Sock 10 Pair Value Pack

Get more bang for your buck with FRUIT OF THE LOOM Girls Socks 10 Pair Value Pack Enjoy soft cotton construction, soft stretch spandex for improved fi...

$7.99

+$4.50 shipping
Free Country Girl’s Down Hooded Coat-blue-xl 16-nwt

Free Country Girl’s Down Hooded Coat-blue-xl 16-nwt

Listing is for one Girl’s Free Country Power Down Coat with Faux Fur trim on hood in Blue in size XL (16). The coat has a removable faux fur trim on...
eBay

$22.99

+$6.50 shipping
Country Girl Boots: Bella Flowy V-Neck Tank Top

Country Girl Boots: Bella Flowy V-Neck Tank Top

Country girls do it with their boots on! Customize a funny and cute tank top with any saying you want! This art features the silhouette of a pair of c...
Customized Girl

$26.97

FREE Shipping
Swamp Girl/swamp Country Dvd

Swamp Girl/swamp Country Dvd

Two Southern fried exploitation films are compiled in this special edition from Something Weird Video. In SWAMP GIRL, a baby, abandoned by her alcohol...
eBay

$10.42

+$2.99 shipping
Girl's Free Country Power Down Vest Ultra Warm, Ultra Light Pinkl- 14/16

Girl's Free Country Power Down Vest Ultra Warm, Ultra Light Pinkl- 14/16

GIRL'S FREE COUNTRY POWER DOWN VEST ULTRA WARM ULTRA LIGHT DOWN VEST HOT PINK Features/Description: This girls’ lightweight down vest has superior c...
eBay
1Line Sports H20 Girl T-Shirt - White - Medium

1Line Sports H20 Girl T-Shirt - White - Medium

1Line Sports has the swim-related accessories for you!
SwimOutlet.com

$11.95

+$4.99 shipping