Click to see larger image
The Deer Hunter (DVD, 1998, Limited Edition Packaging; Widescreen)
(34 Epinions reviews)
Epinions Product Rating:
The Deer Hunter - War Is Hell
Dec 28, 2007
Review by AliventiAsylum
Rated a Very Helpful Review
Pros:cast, story, cinematography
Cons:very long and at the same time I would have liked a Director's cut
The Bottom Line: The Deer Hunter doesn't come off as pro or anti-war to me. It just seems to speak to the experience of fighting for your country.
I grew up in the shadow of the Viet Nam war. The time I came of age in was before the fall of the Berlin Wall, when communism was still considered a deep threat to us as a people and a culture, rather than a source of cheap labor and financing our growing national debt. At the same time, our conviction that we were the strongest country in the world was a bit shaken by what had happened in that country in southeast Asia. Unlike movies like Rambo which attempt to take on the aftermath of the war by changing the ending, movies like The Deer Hunter dealt with the harsh reality of what happened.
Recommend this product?
The movie opens by introducing us to a group of Pennsylvania steel workers. The buddies are quite tight, as exhibited by their behavior prior to the wedding of one of the men. What's more important is that these men are indicative of many during this time. they could have been defense workers on Long Island, textile workers in Massachusetts, oil workers out in Texas, etc.
More than an hour is spent showing the bond between Michael, Stan, Steven, Nick, Axel, and John before they head to Viet Nam. As Steve is married in an elaborate Greek Orthodox ceremony, they make plans for a last hunting trip together as well.
Once in Viet Nam, Michael, Nick, and Steven become prisoners of war. Their VietCong captors use them for entertainment, forcing them to play Russian roulette with partially-loaded pistols. They escape and make their way back to the safe zone. However, Steven elects not to leave and gets swallowed up into the underground world where they play Russian roulette for money.
Michael does return home and has trouble adjusting. Not only must he deal with the guilt over a blossoming relationship with Stevens girlfriend, Linda, but also with the guilt for having left his friends behind. After talking with Steven at a Veterans hospital, Michael returns to VietNam, determined to find Nick and bring him home.
Ill get the films faults out of the way first. Its long; really long. There are plenty of times where the length bogs the story down, especially in this world now where movie viewers have become conditioned to fast-paced, action-packed war movies. However, once I got past expecting a war film and instead accepting it as a character-driven film about the group of friends, my expectations changed as well.
As a character piece, its excellent. The group of young men transcend boundaries and speak to the innocence of the time, both in their age and of us as a country. In a documentary I recently watched on World War II, one of the testimonials from a veteran states how wars are always fought by young men because only they have the mentality to believe they are invincible. This is exemplified by the attitude of the steelworkers in The Deer Hunter.
It also takes on a different perspective knowing what happened to the U.S. steel industry in the last twenty to thirty years. In the beginning, it would seem that these blue-collar workers had strong jobs in a community where they had good roots. However, knowing how things have changed over the years, the promise of the American dream was not going to hold up at home, either.
The acting is superb. Robert DeNiro is excellent and carries much of the film, even if its an ensemble cast. His counterpart is Christopher Walken. Watching him in the series of campy horror film roles hes taken of late makes me cringe when I think of the stellar performance he gives here. The POW scenes with these two men made me feel the anguish and I was holding my breath waiting for the outcome. Few films and performances can do that.
Meryl Streep was only in her second big-screen role in The Deer Hunter and holds her own on a screen crowded with men. She doesnt come off like Scarlett OHara following the Civil War when shes with Michael, something the role could have ended up being. Instead, shes got an inner strength that seems to be like shes moving towards something she has always felt is inevitable. This is a must-see to really get a feel for why she is considered such an amazing actress.
The cinematography is great. From the grittiness of the Pennsylvania steel town to the bleakness of the foreign country, the right atmosphere is created over and over. I could see the bright spots, especially during the wedding, but at the same time these were people who were never going to rise to the top of the pile in life. The hunting scenes where they go on their trip are brighter, creating a time of more optimism and happiness.
Director Michael Cimino cut more than an hour from his final cut, and I wish The Deer Hunter had either been allowed to flow naturally and tell the story the way he wanted it to unfold. Yes, It would have been longer, but I think the pace would have been better and it wouldnt have felt as long. I did watch the deleted and extended scenes in the extras, but I found it was really hard to envision the film complete with them and would have preferred a Directors cut release.
The Deer Hunter won Oscars for Best Picture and Best Director, among others. It deserved it. Its a powerful film that doesnt come off as either pro or anti-war, but just shows how the experience affected the men who went over believing in what they were doing. If you didnt know we had lost the war, you wouldnt after watching this as it doesnt do anything to try to convince one way or the other. It is a powerful testimonial as to what those we ask to lay their lives on the line for this country experience, both during and after the fight.
• Audio Commentary with Cinematographer Vilmos Zsigmond and Film Journalist Bob Fisher
• Deleted and Extended Scenes
• Original Theatrical Trailer
• Production Notes
© 2007 Patti Aliventi
Read all comments (4)
Share this product review with your friends