The V-Discs: Columbia Years: 1943-45 [Box] by Frank Sinatra (CD, Sep-1994, 2 Discs, Legacy)

1 consumer review
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

The "missing link" in Sinatra's early Columbia career

Mar 30, 2008
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review

Pros:Amazing rare recordings of Sinatra from during the '42-44 recording ban, including never-recorded-after songs

Cons:None

The Bottom Line: Essential listening and a perfect companion to Sinatra: A Voice In Time.


What should have been a momentous occasion, that of Frank Sinatra's signing to Columbia and striking out on a solo career after fronting for Harry James and Tommy Dorsey, was nearly silent due to a commercial recording ban enforced by the Musicians Union from mid-1942 to 1944. Because the ban affected instrumental musicians, vocal-only recordings were allowed, meaning that Sinatra and Axel Stordahl had to come up with alternate vocal-backed arrangements that may not have ordinarily been chosen. The second loophole was that instrumentals were allowed on V-Discs, free recordings for the sole use of GIs overseas that were supposed to be destroyed when the war ended (the Library of Congress was allowed to keep one of each disc for posterity).

Sinatra's V-Disc material encompasses 53 songs on two CDs, including material from airchecks as well as studio performances. There are many well-known Sinatra Columbia tunes such as All of Me, Nancy with the Laughing Face, Close to You, Ol' Man River, All the Things You Are, and She's Funny That Way, but many of the brightest gems are songs that Sinatra never got around to recording commercially, such as Long Ago and Far Away, You've Got a Hold On Me, Hot Time in the Town of Berlin, Just Close Your Eyes, Come Rain or Come Shine and Noel Coward's I'll Follow My Secret Heart.

Guests include Dinah Shore, The Pied Pipers and Tommy Dorsey. The remastering and clean-up of these decades-old songs is flawless, and Sinatra's charm is as fresh as ever. His transition from boy singer to teen idol shows him singing with remarkable poise and confidence, and Axel Stordahl's touch is unmistakable. The liner notes are courtesy of George Simon, Roy Hemming, and Will Friedwald. Amazingly, none of these 53 recordings are represented on Columbia's massive (and out-of-print) 12-CD Sinatra box set. This is absolutely essential listening for fans of Sinatra and 1940s popular music.


Recommend this product? Yes


Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!


Related Deals You Might Like...

Five Red Caps - 1943-45 [cd New]

Five Red Caps - 1943-45 [cd New]

Liner Note Author: Dave Penny.
eBay

$13.67

FREE Shipping
Best Years Of Our Lives 1943 [cd New]

Best Years Of Our Lives 1943 [cd New]

Liner Note Author: Michael Highton.Recording information: Chicago (02/18/1942); Hollywood (02/18/1942); New York (02/18/1942); Screen Guild Theatre, H...
eBay

$15.38

FREE Shipping
Lunceford,jimmie & His Orchestra - 1943-45 Broadcasts [cd New]

Lunceford,jimmie & His Orchestra - 1943-45 Broadcasts [cd New]

Liner Note Author: Kevin Hagopian.Recording information: 06/26/1943-08/03/1945.Jimmie Lunceford's wartime orchestra is featured on selections from eig...
eBay

$6.31

FREE Shipping
Sahara (1943)
Walmart.com

$9.99

FREE Shipping
Benson,ivy - 1943-49-ivy Benson & Her All [cd New]

Benson,ivy - 1943-49-ivy Benson & Her All [cd New]

& Her All Girls Band.Recorded in England and Germany between 1943 and 1949. Includes liner notes by Tony Middleton.Personnel: Ivy Benson (alto, clarin...
eBay

$17.49

FREE Shipping
Camouflage (1943)
Walmart.com

$2.00

FREE Shipping
Girl Crazy (1943)
Walmart.com

$2.99

FREE Shipping
Original 1943 Radio  - Phantom Of The Opera: The Radio Broadcast Of - Cd

Original 1943 Radio - Phantom Of The Opera: The Radio Broadcast Of - Cd

Liner Note Author: Tony Thomas .Recording information: Lux Radio Theatre (09/13/1943).Unknown Contributor Roles: Susannah Foster ; Basil Rathbone; Nel...
eBay

$6.61

+$2.99 shipping
Mr. Lucky (1943)
Walmart.com

$2.99

FREE Shipping