Yankee Doodle Dandy (DVD, 2003, 2-Disc Set, Two-Disc Special Edition) Reviews
Click to see larger image

Yankee Doodle Dandy (DVD, 2003, 2-Disc Set, Two-Disc Special Edition)

48 ratings (17 Epinions reviews)
Epinions Product Rating: Excellent
5 stars
11
4 stars
5
3 stars
1
2 stars
1 star
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

Where Can I Buy It?

$16.77
Free Shipping eBay
$19.37
23.88
+$4.97 shipping Walmart.com
$19.97
+$1.97 shipping eBay

Yankee Doodle Dandy (1942)

Oct 20, 1999
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review

Pros:energy, Cagney, Huston, sets, humor

Cons:sometimes melodramatic, corny, or simplistic

"Yankee Doodle Dandy" is a biography of legendary Broadway performer, composer, director and producer George M. Cohan. James Cagney, better known for playing gangsters, won his only Oscar for Best Actor portraying the legendary Cohan. Although many would consider the film hopelessly outdated and corny today, it was one of the biggest films of 1942. That was also the year of "Casablanca", and both films had the same director in Michael Curtiz.

Cohan was born in 1878 into a family of Vaudeville performers, and was already a stage veteran when he produced his first Broadway hit at age 25, "Little Johnny Jones". The accent is on Cohan the composer, and his most famous songs (e.g. "Grand Old Flag", "Over There") become elaborate play-within-a-play productions. While blaring and often fervidly patriotic, the melodies are powerful and memorable. What is more remarkable is Cagney's performance as a dancer, and the hard work he put into imitating Cohan's style both shows and pays off.

Cohan's life story gets a Hollywood treatment, meaning that relationships and events are both simplified and exaggerated. The simplification is necessary given the ground (an entire lifetime) that must be covered. His long partnership with writer Sam Harris (Richard Whorf) becomes a few jokes and a handshake, and important career turns are reduced to a single scene. The exaggerations take away some of the credibility, however: Cohan at age 13 (Douglas Croft) is a brat to top all brats, while a deathbed scene is as maudlin as any Hollywood has created.

Still, one has to admire the cleverness of the screenplay (by Robert Buckner and Edmund Joseph), and few can deliver the witty lines with the timing that Cagney has. The sets and costumes are as good as expected, and the supporting cast is very good. Especially welcome is Walter Huston playing Cohan's father. He's remembered most for his role as the old prospector in "Treasure of the Sierra Madre", but his performance here reminds us of his range and talent. Cagney's sister Jeanne plays Cohan's sister Josie, and Eddie Foy Jr. has an amusing cameo playing his own father. Joan Leslie is smiling blandness as Cohan's wife Mary, but that can be blamed on the character, and her performance is surprisingly mature for her young age of 17.

Cohan's corny musicals were out of fashion by the late 1920s, but his career had a revival in 1937. He played President Franklin Roosevelt in "I'd Rather Be Right", which lampooned Roosevelt's aggressive politics. It is ironic to see Cagney as Roosevelt dancing nimbly on stage, when the real Roosevelt had spent his twelve years as President unable to use his legs. Of course, the full extent of Roosevelt's crippling from polio was not disclosed to the public during his lifetime.

Cohan lived to see Cagney play him on the silver screen, but he died in November of 1942. "Yankee Doodle Dandy" grossed over five million dollars, quite a sum in those days, and was nominated for eight Academy Awards. In addition to Cagney's Oscar, Ray Heindorf and Heinz Roemheld won for Best Music, and Nathan Levinson for Best Sound. Curtiz was nominated for Best Director (he would win the next year for "Casablanca"). Huston was nominated for Best Supporting Actor, Robert Buckner for Best Writing, and the film was nominated for Best Picture. (70/100)


Recommend this product? Yes


Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!


1-4 of 4 best deals

An outstanding musical about the life and times of George M. Cohan, playwright, entertainer, composer and patriot. Academy Award Nominations: 8, inclu...
eBay
Store Rating: 4.0

Free Shipping
A nostalgic view of the golden era of show business and the man who made it glitter--George M. Cohan. His early days, triumphs, songs, musicals and ro...
Walmart.com
23.88
+$4.97 shipping
An outstanding musical about the life and times of George M. Cohan, playwright, entertainer, composer and patriot. Academy Award Nominations: 8, inclu...
eBay
Store Rating: 4.0
+$1.97 shipping
An outstanding musical about the life and times of George M. Cohan, playwright, entertainer, composer and patriot. Academy Award Nominations: 8, inclu...
eBay
Store Rating: 4.0
1-4 of 4 best deals     Why are these stores listed?