Goodfella's

Pros: it's real good
Cons: The name of the pizzeria conjures up images of the evil Italian mob.

This review is based on the Goodfella's located on Hylan Boulevard in Staten Island NY My History with This Place I remember when Goodfella's had opened in my neighborhood. It had to be close to 10 years ago now, (1994). I live in ...

Pros: Vodka Pizza, Apple Pie Pizza
Cons: service, price, parking and atmosphere.

My Wife, loves Goodfellas, I just can't figure out why. I have been going on and off, for about six years now. The service is lousy, quite honestly, its teenagers. This restaurant, was at one time very good, in fact it was quaint. Then they expanded...

Pros: Tasty food-
Cons: Crowded tables, wobbly chairs

Went with my in-laws and husband, each of us had an appetizer and main course. Chicken dishes are tender and flavorful. The scungelli was served a little cold,could have been better. A little crowded had to wait for about 1/2 hour on a Saturday...

Pros: Great food and excellent courteous service.
Cons: None

The food and the service are fantastic. I would highly recommed this fine pizzeria to anyone looking to enjoy great italian food or just for desert there incredible selection of deserts and italian ices and ice cream are second to none!!!!!