MAC Liquidlast Liner

Pros: completely waterproof, colors gorgeous,can be used as eyeshadow base
Cons: tricky to apply, challenging to get off, expensive

As many of you know, I am a makeup artist. If you don't know that, well, you do now. I am constantly looking for colorful useful tools to use in makeup. MAC is one of those companies that is infamous when it comes to unusual makeup tools. NOT ...

Pros: Budgeproof, smudgeproof, waterproof! Really intense black color. I love this eyeliner!
Cons: Takes practice to apply, the brush it comes with is horrible. Can be messy.

I have really oily skin, so any eyeliner I put on gives me raccoon eyes in no time, and I spend the day wiping under my eyes with tissues to clear off the eyeliner smudges.  If I put on eye moisturizer before I put on makeup, I might as well ...

Pros: Actually stays put and looks great! Wonderful array of colors offered.
Cons: Tricky to apply (i.e. takes a bit of practice).

I've tried every conceivable smudge-proof, smear proof gel and liquid eyeliner available and MAC Liquidlast liner is the only one that stays put and looks great. It is, however, a bit tricky to apply as it goes on thick and dries quickly. The best ...

Pros: WATERPROOF, SMUDGE PROOF, LASTS FOREVER! GREAT COLORS!
Cons: Application (if not experienced), Removal if you don't have proper makeup remover (oil based)

This has to be the best liquid liner ever invented. I used it for a night out it never smudged, flaked, or fell off. After a long night out I went to sleep without taking my makeup off and I awoke the next morning to find my eye makeup still completely ...

Pros: NONE.
Cons: Leaks, color fades, brush is awful.

I use all MAC products, except for the eyeliners. I usually use Chanel liquid eyeliner in black but I decided to give Liquidlast a try after reading about in Cosmo. BAD IDEA. It seemed to come out great at first, but when I went to the bathroom to wash my hands, I look up in the mirror and see that the liquid liner had leaked up to the crease of my eye! Half of my eyelid was covered in black liner. I always let my liquid liner dry first so there was no reason for this. I also noticed that the color faded very quickly. I would not buy this again!