Neutrogena Weightless Volume Wax-Free Mascara

Pros: Didn't irritate my eyes, even with contact lenses
Cons: R E A D on....

I love mascara. I own about 7 tubes right now and have also recently thrown out 2 or 3 tubes. I have a couple of favorites that I’ll probably never be without, but I’m always open to trying new formulas. Have you seen all the Neutrogena...

Pros: Lightweight.
Cons: Clumpy, smears, brittle lashes...

What Neutrogena says: Full, weightless lashes,Wax-free, No clumps or smudges.Breakthrough wax-free formula eliminates traditional mascara wax clumping, smudging and smearing. Lashes look healthy and feel weightless, not heavy, stiff or brittle....

Pros: very natural looking, leaves lashes soft, nice looking tube
Cons: Bad scent, some flaking, not much in the way of volume or drama

Last week I went to the drugstore in search of a new mascara. This is not a product I often purchase; I either use much too old tubes or rely on gift-with-purchases so I was not too sure what to choose. I turned to the Neutrogena display and noticed the ...

Pros: Goes on without clumps, enhances natural looking lashes
Cons: Will not create drama

I used to never pay for mascara; it always came free with other purchases. But over the years none of those free samples worked for me. So, I started to buy mascara. Anything new that came out I'd try. I purchased Neutrogena Weightless Volume ...

Pros: Light coverage, easy to use, easy to find in drugstores. Gentle.
Cons: Coverage might be too light for some.

I recently decided to start wearing mascara. I have freakishly long eyelashes, and never felt it necessary. However, lately I've been noticing after my morning makeup ritual, the various powders and shadows land on my lashes and render them not very ...

Pros: No flaking, smearing, or smudging. Generally, a great daytime mascara. Cheap.
Cons: The smell?

Context Mascara can be the most problematic cosmetic. It's prone to run, unless you buy a waterproof version. If it's waterproof it might smear and that's a hell of a lot harder to clean up if you don't have eye make-up remover on hand. In any ...

Pros: Easy to apply, very natural looking.
Cons: Maybe too natural looking for some and the smell.

So here I am in my local drugstore, cursing the Covergirl mascara that suddenly betrayed me with stinging eyes and clumping. Oh well, I thought. At least there's a sale today. And so I found Neutrogena Weightless Volume Wax-Free Mascara . ...

Pros: Very natural and light look, no smudging, great with contacts
Cons: Might not be dramatic enough for some, expensive for what you get

Let me preface this by saying that I'm an extreme minimalist when it comes to makeup. Mascara and a tinted gloss are the extent of my regimen. I have a naturally smooth complexion and hate to feel "made up." Therefore, I may be approaching this...

Pros: No flaking, clumping, or rubbing off underneath eyes. Great for contact-lens wearers or makeup minimalists.
Cons: Less dramatic effect than might be seen from other mascaras

I have been using this mascara for quite some time now (around three years). It is my all-time favorite, and whenever I stray, I go right back. I can see why some people might not like it. It is different from other mascaras. It doesn't have the same ...

Pros: Natural, easy to use, no flakes or clumps, comfortable, good for sensitive eyes
Cons: Not very noticeable, too expensive for what it offers

"Weightless Volume" belies the laws of physics. There is no such thing. Neutrogena seems to be trying to prove this through their mascara (who knew?). What I'm saying is, yeah, the mascara feels weightless. But does it provide volume? Can you even see ...

Pros: long wearing
very natural looking
truly "weightless"
not irritating to sensitive eyes
easily removed
lacks drama
Cons: lacks drama (both a pro and a con for me)

I initially purchased Neutrogena Weightless Volume wax-free mascara because I am tired of mascaras that make me look like I have spiders growing out of my eyelids.  I have fairly dense, long lashes with a good amount of natural curl... but they are ...

Pros: Washes off well
Cons: Very light, not enough volume, eyelashes are now breaking off!

Ok so when I first discovered this mascara, I really liked it. I liked that it washed off easy and didn't leave black residue under my eyes. Its doesn't give lots of volume, its a very light mascara like others have stated. I am on my second tube now and my eyelashes are all falling out and breaking off! Do not buy this mascara!

Pros: Lengthens, naturally thin (no clumps), opens up eyes, cheap!
Cons: Can't cry or else it will fade, does flake on occasion.

I love this mascara. It looks completely natural and makes my lashes so long. Granted, I apply about 5-10 continuous coats of mascara per eye (!!!) but it's totally worth. An it's nice not to have to use any remover of soap, just water. The only problem with that is if you cry, it will slowly but surely disappear. Every once in a while,it flakes onto my lower lids, but it's easily wiped away.

Pros: None
Cons: See above

Weightless color? just not dramatic enough for my eyes.
Boring tube and pricey for what you get. I really wanted to like it after what I paid for it. What a waste!

Pros: No clumps or smears. Lashes feel soft and natural
Cons: It takes a few coats to build up the volume

I've been buying mascara for over 30 years, so I've tried them all. The Neutrogena Wax-Free Mascara is the only one I've ever used that truly does not smear. I've always had a problem with the 'raccoon eyes', constantly wiping the black smudges from under my lashes. I do not have that problem with the Weightless Volume Mascara. I'm on my second tube and will continue to buy it.
Unfortunately I have rather skimpy lashes and have to put on 3 or 4 coats of this mascara to get the volume I want, so it does take some extra time to apply.