Review by msmorvay
July, 02 2012
Pros: Cool lobby, nice fitness center
Cons: Tiny cramped room, faulty temperature equipment in our room.
Review by r_liebo
October, 25 2008
Pros: Location (if you like this area), all needs met, room size
Cons: location (if you like another), no character, dated styling
Review by factotum
April, 14 2008
Pros: Great location
Cons: Indifferent service, bland accommodations, high price
Review by khorrell
January, 07 2008
Pros: Super Location, Clean and comfortable room, Great Rates are possible.
Cons: Room rates can be high, excessively high room service costs, dated atmosphere.
Review by sophiesdad
November, 25 2005
Pros: Good location, clean rooms, courteous staff.
Cons: VERY expensive food and room service.
Review by belynch
October, 04 2005
Pros: Service. Location. Clean. Comfortable. Quiet.
Cons: Lacked a wow factor.
Review by sheriffdog
August, 27 2005
Pros: Good midtown location, inexpensive shuttle service to both airports across the street. Nice renovation.
Cons: Impersonal, smelly, mold in bathrooms, tiny bathrooms, extremely noisy neighborhood, but hey, it's New York.
Review by ctsoapfan
May, 03 2005
Pros: LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION
Cons: Overpriced Restaurants
Review by Brettkatt
July, 16 2004
Pros: Fitness center for hotel guest. Near most tourist sites. Good rate.
Cons: Dark lobby, restaurant staff was not good, Not given important information.
Review by jrr1
May, 18 2004
Pros: location, location, location! Nice renovated room
Cons: size is a bit small
Review by popsrocks
October, 30 2003
Pros: Right next to Grand Central Station and the Chrysler Building.
Cons: HUGE Lobby that is cold and not personal.
Review by sarahalm
May, 13 2003
Pros: Best location in New York City! Great fitness center
Cons: No coffee makers or mini bars
Review by uraniumorchids
March, 16 2003
Pros: Central, transit-friendly midtown location.
Cons: Outdated rooms, spotty service.
Review by durems
January, 11 2003
Pros: Wonderful location; attractive lobby area
Cons: Paper-thin walls; uncomfortable beds and pillows; poor housekeeping
Review by jcmcmousetrap
December, 29 2002
Pros: Location, Location, Location!
Review by candidreview
December, 23 2002
Pros: Quiet,decent size rooms,Location
Cons: Bad valet service
Review by tombarnes
May, 02 2002
Pros: Excellent location for business or leisure travel, clean and efficient
Cons: A sad replacement for the old Hotel Commodore
Review by DAnneC
April, 29 2002
Pros: Great location, courteous staff, wide range of guest services
Cons: Generally rather expensive
Review by mrhonda
July, 11 2001
Pros: Great Location and not too expensive.
Cons: Rooms small and outdated.
Review by jdhauer
April, 15 2001
Pros: first stay was good
Cons: NO BED, smelly, poor service
Review by helicopter12
December, 05 2000
Pros: Almost everything
Cons: Could get something alike for cheaper