Epinions.com 
Join Epinions | Learn More! | Sign In   
           
HomeMediaVideos & DVDsGods and Generals
Gods and Generals

Gods and Generals

Overall Rating: Product Rating: 2.5
Action Factor:
Special Effects:
Suspense:
$8.67 at DeepDiscount.com Featured Store
$2.53 at HotMovieSale.com Featured Store
$4.49 at iNetVideo.com Featured Store

Compare Prices Read Reviews (34) View Details Write a Review
Showing 1-15 of 34 reviews Page 1 2 3 - View all   Next
Sort by
Product Rating
Sort by
Review Date
Product Rating:Product Rating: 1.0
Action Factor:
Special Effects:
Suspense:
Compare Prices

Can't Decide Between 'War is Hell' And 'Those Were The Days'- Gods and Generals

by Vormancian Epinions Most Popular Authors - Top 500, Jul 30 '03
Pros: It's really pretty.
Cons: It's really pretentious.
'Gods and Generals' is probably the most beautiful movie ever made. Unfortunately, it is hard to avo ...
Read the full review
Product Rating:Product Rating: 3.0
Action Factor:
Special Effects:
Suspense:
Compare Prices

Gods and Generals in the Civil War

by phungus phungus is a Top Reviewer on Epinions in Movies, Epinions Most Popular Authors - Top 100, Jul 04 '07
Pros: Stephen Lang as Stonewall Jackson
Cons: Way too long, boring battle sequences
Gods and Generals is an incredibly long and somewhat boring Civil War movie from the same people who made Gettysburg. This $60 million box office bomb, paid for by Ted Turner, stars Robert Duvall, Stephen Lang, and Jeff Daniels. As much as ...
Read the full review
Product Rating:Product Rating: 4.0
 
Compare Prices

Preserve The Union or Defend States Rights?

by mcmaster Epinions Most Popular Authors - Top 100, Mar 04 '03
Pros: Some excellent acting & cinematography. A very accurate portrayal of Thomas "Stonewall" Jackson.
Cons: A bit to long for most folks.
I thought Gods and Generals was a good movie. That being said, It was nowhere near as good as Gettysburg which was released in 1993 and also directed by Ron Maxwell. Keep in mind I believe Gettysburg is among the best...
Read the full review
Product Rating:Product Rating: 1.0
 
Compare Prices

Gods and Generals-The Neverending Battle

by RcknRbn3 Epinions Most Popular Authors - Top 1000, Feb 22 '03
Pros: the landscapes, costumes, that it ended
Cons: lack of direction, script, unbearable 3hours 36 minutes
I did not heed the warnings from the local entertainment review on Gods and Generals, I ignored the wearied cries of those that braved this movie before me, and I am paying the price today, still disturbed and disappointed. I am not the typical...
Read the full review
Product Rating:Product Rating: 5.0
 
Compare Prices

Gods and Generals: A Civil War Film of Epic Proportions.

by Ironcladd Epinions Most Popular Authors - Top 500, Feb 23 '03
Pros: Historical accuracy, drama, cool war action, and acting.
Cons: Too long for most people who don't like history.
Gods and Generals: A Civil War Film of Epic Proportions.

The American Civil War was the bloodiest war in American history, with over 620,000 deaths occurring between 1861 and 1865. Accurate portrayals of this conflict in the film industry...
Read the full review
Product Rating:Product Rating: 1.0
 
Compare Prices

Gods and Generals: Cheese Balls Trump Musket Balls

by NFP , Feb 24 '03
Pros: The recreation of the Battle of Fredericksburg.
Cons: Virtually everything else
Civil War buffs generally don’t go to see movies about the Civil War to see good movies. They go to see Civil War movies because they can’t get enough of the Civil War. If they get a good movie in the process, it’s gravy.

There is,...
Read the full review
Product Rating:Product Rating: 1.0
 
Compare Prices

War Is Hell And So Is Sitting Through This Movie

by alwaystuesday , Feb 21 '03
Pros: It eventually ends.
Cons: It begins, last fours hours and accomplishes nothing.
Where to be begin. Take one of the most important events in the history of the United States, a bunch of melodramatic overacting, bad camera work and editing and cram it all into a short little film of four hours. And what you have is crap.

...
Read the full review
Product Rating:Product Rating: 4.0
Action Factor:
Special Effects:
Suspense:
Compare Prices

Flawed, but fascinating

by catu11us , Jun 09 '04
Pros: Historically accurate (mostly), giving viewers a good idea what the Southern rebellion was like.
Cons: Unfocussed, with huge gaps in events, uncovered by any narrative.
“Gods and Generals” is the first (although second released) in a trilogy of films recreating the eastern front of the Slaveholders’ Rebellion (“Civil War”). The first film, “Gettysburg”, was a well-realized dramatization of ...
Read the full review
Product Rating:Product Rating: 4.0
 
Compare Prices

A well made glimpse into Civil War America.

by openroad Epinions Most Popular Authors - Top 100, Feb 25 '03
Pros: Historically accurate, realistic battle scenes, keeps the past remembered and alive.
Cons: Some unnecessary dialogue, too long for those with short attention spans.
Details

Gods and Generals

In theaters: 2/21/03

Directed by: Ronald F. Maxwell

Jeff Daniels ... Lt. Col. Joshua Lawrence Chamberlain

Stephen Lang ... General Thomas Jonathan "Stonewall"...
Read the full review
Product Rating:Product Rating: 1.0
 
Compare Prices

AS SLOW AS MOLASSES AND JUST AS GOOEY

by brotherthor , Feb 22 '03
Pros: Anti-war message; the intermission in the middle of this 4 hour movie
Cons: Movie was too LONG AND SLOW; MUMBLED LINES; no real plot
The film Gods and Generals is essentially an agonizingly boring and dull biography of the life of Stonewall Jackson during the Civil war. Jackson is shown as a preachy and annoying Bible-thumping/quoting evangelist who sees himself as the instrument of...
Read the full review
Product Rating:Product Rating: 2.0
 
Compare Prices

Mighty Stonewall

by kjmansfield , Feb 22 '03
Pros: Historical accuracy in great detail, Jeff Daniels as Lt.Col. Chamberlain, Stephen Lang as Lt.Gen. Jackson.
Cons: Excessive length, Victorian manners, excessively pro-southern tone.
I have just come from seeing "Gods and Generals", all four hours of it. Reviews thus far have been scathing, and not without some justification. First, let me state my credentials up front. I am a history buff and Civil War reenactor, so I liked this...
Read the full review
Product Rating:Product Rating: 5.0
 
Compare Prices

Thoughts from an 18 year old.

by opus11 , Feb 25 '03
Pros: accuracy,touching,amazing!
Cons: none
I eagerly awaited the 7 o'clock showing of the movie 'Gods and Generals'. It was Friday, opening night. And so it was to begin, and so I was to see the greatest war film of my lifetime! I will honestly say I was more than pleased; I was elated at...
Read the full review
Product Rating:Product Rating: 2.0
 
Compare Prices

Gods and Generals: The Definitive Review

by kembry , Feb 21 '03
Pros: A traditional take on the Civil War. Good acting.
Cons: Bad writing, bad direction, terrible editing.
When I was a television reporter, I'll never forget talking to a historian that said you can never understand America until you come to grips with the impact of the Civil War. The cinematic tradition that's covered this subject has generally been...
Read the full review
Product Rating:Product Rating: 1.0
 
Compare Prices

Such a shame!

by magda678 , Feb 19 '03
Pros: Excellent cinematography, historical accuracy, good costumes
Cons: Stultifyingly long and boring, mawkish stilted writing, no clear dramatic focus
First let me say that the reason I was looking forward to seeing this film was that I loved Gettysburg. Since Gods and Generals was made by pretty much the same set of people, I had high hopes for it, especially after I heard from some people involved...
Read the full review
Product Rating:Product Rating: 2.0
Action Factor:
Special Effects:
Suspense:
Compare Prices

The South Will Bore You Again and Again and Again..

by bloodymadness , May 30 '07
Pros: Very accurate. Very very accurate.
Cons: Biased, and drawn out.
2003s Gods and Generals was the film adaptation of the novel of the same name by Jeff Shaar. The film takes place during the Civil War's early years (1861-1863) before leading up to the decisive Battle of Gettysburg. As a history buff myself, I ...
Read the full review
Showing 1-15 of 34 reviews Page 1 2 3 - View all Next


1-4 of 13 stores Store Rating Price
FREE Standard Shipping (In stock)
DVDs. Gods and Generals More at DeepDiscount.com
DeepDiscount.com
Store Rating: 4.5
(In stock)
The story of General 'Stonewall' Jackson and his role for the Confederacy in the Civil War. More at HotMovieSale.com
HotMovieSale.com
(Stock status: N/A)
Product DetailsOriginal Title:Gods and GeneralsActors: Jeff Daniels - Kevin Conway - Mark J. Nichols - Mira Sorvino - Robert Duvall - Stephen LangCon... More at iNetVideo.com
iNetVideo.com
1-866-501-iNet (4638)
(In stock)
J&R Music and Computer World
Store Rating: 4.5

Showing 1-4 of 13 stores
   View all deals       Why are these stores listed?



Subscribe to More Reviews on Videos & DVDs
Get the RSS Feed: - Add to My Yahoo!: Add to My Yahoo! - Add to Google Homepage: Add to Google

Help | Member Center | Message Boards | Site Rules | User Agreement | Privacy Policy | Site Index | Topic Index  
About Epinions | Careers | Contact Epinions | Advertising  

Epinions | Shopping.com | Rent.com | Free Classifieds | Price Comparison UK

Shopping.com Network © 1999-2009 Shopping.com, Inc. Trademark Notice

Epinions.com periodically updates pricing and product information from third-party sources,
so some information may be slightly out-of-date. You should confirm all information before relying on it.